To want "my" wedding ring?

(52 Posts)
kirsten123 Sun 25-May-14 19:58:09

Hi all,

Ex-fiancé and I get engaged over a year ago at which time he bought my engagement ring and the matching wedding band (and a band for himself). Entirely out of his own money. We split up last month when he said he didn't actually want to get married to anyone. Ever. (Threads about this in relationship forum). This was despite him allowing me moving from Scotland to be with him. (He's a narcissist).

He let me keep the engagement ring (on the basis I don't sell it) and I still wear it on the other hand (partly as I don't want to leave it in my new place as don't trust new roommates yet!)

Question is - am I being unreasonable to ask for the wedding band too? I don't want to sell it, I just want it/don't want anyone else to have it/good reminder of my lucky escape!

He is pretty well off and can easily afford to give me it but seemed to suggest I was being cheeky when I asked. I told him to think about it. The engagement ring is worth much more anyway.

Thanks in advance.

Holdthepage Sun 25-May-14 20:02:31

YABU - it isn't your wedding ring because a) you didn't pay for it & b) you didn't get married.

JimmyCorkhill Sun 25-May-14 20:03:17

I think you're supposed to give the engagement ring back so I would say that you shouldn't ask for the wedding band too. However, there is no harm in asking. You have a 50/50 chance of getting it!

picnicbasketcase Sun 25-May-14 20:03:37

Yabu

It's not yours.

CSIJanner Sun 25-May-14 20:05:21

Erm - yes. YABU. He bought it, not you. If you actually got married then I would say yes, but asking when you split before sounds a touch grabby, especially when you got to keep the engagement ring which is "worth much more".

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream Sun 25-May-14 20:06:13

It's not 'yours' in any sense at all

ThatBloodyWoman Sun 25-May-14 20:06:20

The engagement ring was given to you so its yours.
The wedding ring wasn't so it's his.

MinesAPintOfTea Sun 25-May-14 20:06:25

You get to keep the engagement ring as compensation because he reduced your value as a bride but he never gave you the wedding ring. You only get to keep the gifts he gave you, not the ones he was thinking about giving you.

eurochick Sun 25-May-14 20:06:46

YABU. It's not your ring.

WorraLiberty Sun 25-May-14 20:07:14

Fuck me that's some brass neck you've got there! grin

He forked out for all the rings out of his own pocket and you want to keep 2 of them?

Sorry but the phrase 'Jog on' definitely springs to mind!

ZenNudist Sun 25-May-14 20:10:29

Yabu. It's surely an expensive keepsake. Be honest are you just using jewellery as a way to punish him?!

ShakesBootyFlabWobbles Sun 25-May-14 20:10:30

I don't think YABU to ask for it, just like he WNBU to decline.

It is no use to him but he may be able to return it and get his money back. Or you could offer him half price if you really, really want it.

IMHO once you move on and meet/marry someone else, it is very likely you'll never wear either of them. Give up the materiality and let him and the rings go.

AuntieStella Sun 25-May-14 20:10:32

It's not anyone's wedding ring.

It's a piece of jewellery bop ought in anticipation if an event which did not happen, was never given to a recipient and which is therefore totally up to the purchaser to decide what to do with.

Incidentally, if you intend to keep the ring that was once an engagement ring, it is wrong for him to make it conditional. Either it is a straight gift (you keep it, sell it, give it away, whatever you fancy) or it isn't (you give it back)..

TestingTestingWonTooFree Sun 25-May-14 20:13:23

YABU to ask for the other ring.

CoffeeTea103 Sun 25-May-14 20:15:16

Talk about cheeky shock yabu how do you even feel it's ok to ask something like that.

JamJimJam Sun 25-May-14 20:17:47

Why on earth would you want a wedding band for a non-existant marriage? I don't get it.

kirsten123 Sun 25-May-14 20:18:28

Well, he really screwed me over by making me move and then changing his mind re engagement so I had to move out and rent a flat...in some ways I thought it was the least he could do! (He admits I did nothing wrong). And the rings match, so better I have it than it sit in a box in his house?

But I see your points!

magpiegin Sun 25-May-14 20:19:06

Of course it is not your wedding ring. It is a ring he bought and you didn't marry him so it's just a ring he owns. You are being hugely cheeky.

HermioneWeasley Sun 25-May-14 20:19:10

What do you want it for?

Why did you keep the engagement ring?

HermioneWeasley Sun 25-May-14 20:20:17

But you've agreed not to sell the ring, so I don't understand how it benefits you?

kirsten123 Sun 25-May-14 20:21:22

What do people generally do with obsolete wedding/engagement rings?

guitarosauras Sun 25-May-14 20:24:23

I think that it's quite odd that you want it tbh!

Time to move on!

Teeb Sun 25-May-14 20:25:14

Lord you've some cheek.

TaliZorahVasNormandy Sun 25-May-14 20:25:40

I sold my ring and my exes, I had his child to support after he fucked off with another woman.

MrsLettuce Sun 25-May-14 20:26:58

Engagement rings are (rightly) usually given back. Wedding rings, well, tat depends.

YABVU, as is he if he's really said that you can keep it but can't sell it. Either it's yours or it not.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now