Note: Please bear in mind that whilst this topic does canvass opinions, it is not a fight club. You may disagree with other posters but we do ask you please to stick to our Talk Guidelines and to be civil. We don't allow personal attacks or troll-hunting. Do please report any. Thanks, MNHQ.

To have said no to this request?

(75 Posts)
Hayfreever Thu 01-May-14 22:35:35

Dh's son (my ss) 14 doesn't live with us but has asked if he can stay half term (of course), but wants to have a small party here (15/20 kids). I have said no as that is the week before my son starts gcse's and he needs quiet to revise. I have said any time after exams is fine. Dh says I am being unreasonable. Am I?

Infinity8 Thu 01-May-14 22:37:16

I wouldn't allow a teen to have a party in my house, full stop. So you are more reasonable than me!

BerniesBurneze Thu 01-May-14 22:37:24

Yadnbu!! No way. To be honest I almost said yanbu before I read about your son's gcses!

Floggingmolly Thu 01-May-14 22:38:18

That's not a very small party!

Has his mum already said no to having a party at hers? If not, tell him he's welcome to stay at yours but go home for a night for a party!

FunkyBoldRibena Thu 01-May-14 22:40:13

No, party is a no goer from me. No chance.

AlpacaLypse Thu 01-May-14 22:40:52

No, yanbu. The only way to do this sort of thing is to transfer to a 'what if they were whole siblings, would it be okay?' mental state. Which it isn't, so if he wants to have a party it's going to be when it works for everyone else.

And THEN start to think about how you're going to police a teen party smile

Trooperslane Thu 01-May-14 22:44:45

Um no. GCSE's trump everything else.

Hayfreever Thu 01-May-14 22:45:16

Thanks for your replies.. My dd has had parties so I couldn't possibly say no outright, but I know how easily distracted ds is and maths is his first exam.. Have had a flaming row with dh over this as the word 'no' is not in his vocab as far as his kids are concerned, but I have told him this is one occasion I'm not giving in! Thank you for your reassurance I am not being a cow!

Nocomet Thu 01-May-14 22:46:18

YANBU

My house just about copes with ten preteens for a craft party. 15-20 full size teens wouldn't fit full stop.

And absolutely not until DD1's exams are over!

Hayfreever Thu 01-May-14 22:47:47

AlpacaLypse if they were whole siblings it most certainly wouldn't be ok either!

Ledkr Thu 01-May-14 22:48:12

Oh no No no no. I'm on my 4th teen and its never happened yet, I can barely cope with sleepovers.

Hayfreever Thu 01-May-14 22:52:06

Keep it that way Ledkr because once one starts.. We've had big ones here with bouncers on door to confiscate the vodka.. Had to have my grey re-touched the following week!

SpringBreaker Thu 01-May-14 22:54:11

15/20 isnt really a small party if it is in a house.. maybe you could compromise and let him have 5 of his mates over for an evening.. it is only one night so I cant see that disrupting your son too much

PortofinoRevisited Thu 01-May-14 22:57:05

Surely a party would be one evening post 7.30 ish and would not disrupt revision THAT much? I never used to do revision on Sat night.

maddening Thu 01-May-14 22:58:44

If they like skating/bmxing you can often hire skateparks for a couple of hours then take them to pizza hut - they get a special treat but it is outside of the house?

PortofinoRevisited Thu 01-May-14 22:58:52

I used to find Wimbledon a much greater distraction.

maddening Thu 01-May-14 22:59:50

Or go ape or lazer quest

Shewhowines Thu 01-May-14 23:01:01

Well I wouldn't agree to a party like that full stop, but given that one will happen at sometime, I agree that it might as well be on that sat night. One night off revision won't hurt.

UncleT Thu 01-May-14 23:02:33

YANBU. GCSEs are clearly the more important issue here, DH really shouldn't need this explaining.

wheresthelight Thu 01-May-14 23:05:34

My parents allowed parties when I was a teenager and I will allow dsc's and dd to have them but not a cat in hells chances exams are looming!!!

Yadnbu and your dh is being a Twat!

To be honest I would not be surprised if he has asked his mum who has said no and is playing a smart game in knowing daddy will let him!! I would speak to his mum if you are in good terms and see what her take is on it!!

YellowTulips Thu 01-May-14 23:13:17

That's not a small party. Personally I wouldn't allow it at any time of year in the house for either my DSD or DS.

For a birthday I'd rent out a location (village hall or other) for a gathering that size. Unless you have a very large house you are going to be over run and make no mistake - controlling a party that size will be very difficult even of ONLY those invited attend and you don't get gate crashers.

If your DH is so keen I would tell him to pay for and organise a party outside the house. Quite frankly though as there is no mention of this being a special event I think its excessive and pandering - all a bit Disney Dad tbh.

cardamomginger Thu 01-May-14 23:22:29

Good God YANBU!

Bloodyteenagers Thu 01-May-14 23:48:18

His mum has said no.
So he has come to the wimp of a dad who never says no. However, he forgot about you.

Can picture the conversation..
So can I come and stay half term?
Yes.
Some type of thanks... A bit of a pause.. Can I have a party, 20 people at the most...

Sunshinelaulau Thu 01-May-14 23:53:32

If you're ok with a party offer a bigger party after the exams, it'll summer hols then too and u chuck them out in the garden (if we get summer weather)

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now