ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
To not get no make-up nomination?(57 Posts)
Everyone knows what neknomination is, and now no make-up nomination is doing the rounds.
Whilst I think it's good to be confident to post a photo of your completely bare and natural face.
The purpose is it to raise awareness of cancer. Which I can't for the life of me see how this does.
Aibu to just not get the point of it?
I've posted a picture of myself so yes, actually I think you are all being a bit unreasonable. Okay so posting a picture may not "do" an awful lot but it shows that there are people out there who want to band together with their friends & show some solidarity (a few of mine who have had cancer have posted their pictures too). Before anyone gets on their high horses about simply donating instead, in the last 5 years before my son was born I ran Race For Life every year & raised nearly £2,000 to help in the fight for cancer so I think I've done my bit.
Also to the person choosing to unfriend someone over a silly picture, get over yourself!! You clearly can't like the person very much to begin with if you'll unfriend them for something as pathetic as a picture.
Can people not have a bit of well meaning fun anymore, or should we all join the dead serious, dull as ditch water PC brigade? I'm actually finding it fun seeing how beautiful some of my friends are without make up & wondering why they feel the need to constantly cover their natural beauty
It's total bullshit.
Actual does me writing it's bullshit make you aware of cancer?
I'm not stupid. I know it exists. I know actual charities to give money to that do actual work. You with no make up just means you stoopid....
It doesn't show solidarity in any meaningful sense. It's essentially the least effort way to produce the illusion of doing something/caring. That's the problem with social media generally (it can create an illusion of friendship/community/charity/activism which very often displace the actual practices of friendship/community/charity/activism).
And, seriously, does anyone believe that this 'raises awareness'? Everyone is aware of cancer and that it's Not Good. No one needs help with this. What people may well be unaware of are things like the symptoms of specific cancers. But taking 30 seconds to take a photo of yourself in your phone and posting it to Facebook does absolutely nothing to help with that.
I know some people on my facebook who are very self-conscious and it would have taken a lot of courage for them to post their pictures and as expected there are pictures from my more narcissistic friends
who I keep meaning to delete
I really don't see the link between these pictures and cancer, another friend of mine posted symptoms of breast cancer, some of which I didn't know about. Maybe instead of raising awareness of cancer, the selfies should have been done purely to raise their own self esteem and people shared the symptoms to raise awareness of cancer.
Perfect, IceBeing - definitely nicking that one from you!
YANBU, I really can't see why a pic of someone with no make up relates to breast cancer awareness. Maybe I just don't get it.
I have a few on my feed (mostly friends of friends), one man replied to one of the pictures with similar thoughts to me and has been flamed terribly. Apparently he is evil scum and they hope he gets cancer.
This has just made it onto my fb. Not a single pic explains why or how this helps support cancer. Nor can any of them explain how it does when I've pm'd them :-/
Just another excuse for a selfie which the people posting them on my fb hardly needed
Well I have had breast cancer and was asked to do it so I did. I added a sentence saying I wasn't sure what good it would do! I never wear make up anyway. I will leave it up for today then remove it.
In fact you lot made me decide to stop being such a sheep so I have deleted the photo. Most of my fb friends have had breast cancer and all are aware of it. Thanks all.
I have been nominated. I shan't be doing it. The whole thing has had me rolling my eyes since it appeared on my newsfeed yesterday morning.
I have read that it started as some sort of campaign to encourage donations. Take a no make up selfie and donate. But the attention seekers seem to be using it for their own agenda and I haven't seen anyone mention anything about donations on my fb at least. All it is, is "Oh I am sooooo minging" followed by "Oh hunz you arnt, you are gawjuz!" type crap. Fuck all to do with raising awareness! More like massaging each others ego.
I am already raising money for Cancer Research (doing a 10k run soon) so it isn't because I am "heartless" or I "don't care". I very much do after watching 3 loved ones die from this horrible disease. I just won't partake in attention seeking bollocks under the guise of raising awareness just like those statuses that do the rounds, keeping secret from the menz
because it isn't like they get Breast Cancer too yano....
I would prefer to share information on Cancer symptoms and what to look out for, how to check your breasts properly and reminding women and men to do so regularly and men to check their testicles regularly too. Not only that, but to always make sure they attend any tests/examinations IE smears. That sort of thing helps. Not selfies.
whats fun about cancer julia? people having a bit of fun posting make up free selfies to promote awareness of cancer is an insult to all those who have suffered the awfulness of cancer and their families too.
no its an egostroke to most, if people want to make a difference then they can donate.
my dad died horribly from cancer.
As I said on the other thread, post a picture but post a donate link too, that's what I did and I've also made a donation.
Oh God I read this thread and just knew my work colleague would do this- and yes there she is. No mention of donations. The levels of narcissism today never fails to amaze me. It is utterly distasteful.
It's a load of bollocks and I bet 80% of the people posting these stupid bloody photos haven't bothered with the donation. My status on FB today is asking if someone can explain exactly how this is doing the cause favours - so far no one has come up with a sensible answer.
It's making a mockery of a serious illness and it's also making me bloody annoyed.
Well said Calamitously...
I'm getting this too - surprising, my FB friends normally have more sense. All photos of me show me without makeup, I almost never wear it. Have I been breaking some rules?
I am all too aware of cancer, thank you, (as are most people) and my donation via direct debit to cancer research has been running a while. That is the only slight good thing about this - it does seem to be suggesting that people set up direct debits or one-off donations straight to the charity, not via the take-a-cut websites or by expensive-to-organise silly events.
yes, you, Alex Jones
All it does is reveal how disingenuous people are who gush all over others bareface pics saying "you look gorgeous!" when the individual in question looks rough as nails (as I would). I've got your number, fibber.
This is my current Facebook status
Hello to all my Facebook friends who are doing this make up free selfie to raise awareness for cancer. I'm sure that you are all doing it with the best of intentions and feel that you've helped raise awareness of cancer. But let's think about raising awareness - is cancer not something that every single one of us is massively aware of? Is there not one of us here who haven't been touched in some way by this disease?
I work with people who actually have cancer. Every day I see exactly what this shit disease does to their body. Every day, I witness what the treatment I give them does to their body. They have to live their lives with not only the physical scars that can't be covered up with a bit of slap, but also the emotional scars. They have to battle through some pretty horrendous, life changing shit, believe me. Imagine not being able to eat and drink because you physically can't. Imagine having to walk around with a gaping hole where your nose/eye once was. Imagine having to rely on a big tube fitted in your neck so you can breathe. Imagine having a stump where a leg once was. Imagine how it is to feel that you've let your family down by allowing yourself to get cancer because you've made a few bad lifestyle choices.
Helping people with cancer takes money, lots of it, fucking shed loads of it in fact. Taking a photo of yourself with no make up on will do nothing. Nominating friends to do the same will do nothing......it just becomes one of those Facebook games that do the rounds from time to time. Unless you post a make up free selfie and state that you have also given money towards cancer research - that's the only thing that will make this latest Facebook craze a worthwhile initiative. How about putting your hand in your pockets and actually donating some money. Big kudos to those of you who have done so - you've actually made a difference.
And yes, I do have a regular direct debit to cancer research.
I've also posted a screen shot of my donation to cancer research in lieu of a make up free selfie of myself. God, I look bad enough WITH make up on!!!
Anyway - text BEAT to 70099. That will give cancer research £3. And that will be a much more positive action than posting a make up free selfie
Another one here who has been flamed by the sheep. Because I never knew fucking cancer existed either, until I saw a friend's face without make up.
#cancerawareness #nomakeupselfie I feel really silly not as all I posted was money
Shamelessly plagerised from a Ricky Gervais tweet
#cancerawareness #nomakeupselfie I feel really silly now as all I posted was money
Should've left it it the pros
Actually I think it does work! Thousands have posted their picture if even 10% of those people start a conversation about cancer, the a) that's reducing the stigma of the dreaded c word b) someone else may see it and decide to donate if they don't want a picture, that's a donation that wouldn't have happened. Lastly woman may see it and think actually its been a whule since I checked my breasts and do it. The statistics for regularly checking are shocking.
So no it won't cure cancer, yes it is a stunt but it gets people talking. That may get a diagnosis sooner than otherwise would have.
Holiday I kinda agree. I am against the narcissism, but in reality it did prompt me to donate today.
I started the day thinking these selfies were self indulgent and pointless, I've now changed my mind but ONLY if people remember to post the reason for doing it. Remind women to check their breasts TODAY and to donate if they can.
We older ladies may know about breast cancer, but many younger women don't know how to check themselves.
Many older women don't know how to check themselves.
Of all the women who do know how to check themselves, many may have forgotten to recently. Your selfie should prompt them to do so.
Many would think to donate, despite being in a position to.
So yes it does raise awareness and funds, but does so most effectively when accompanied by the clear message as to why!
I've changed my mind about the selfies since realising this, who else will?
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.