Note: Please bear in mind that whilst this topic does canvass opinions, it is not a fight club. You may disagree with other posters but we do ask you please to stick to our Talk Guidelines and to be civil. We don't allow personal attacks or troll-hunting. Do please report any. Thanks, MNHQ.

To think this father shouldn't get a free Xbox One for making a mistake?

(158 Posts)
Topaz25 Tue 10-Dec-13 13:36:22

"A teenager who was scammed into buying a photo of an Xbox One on eBay for £450 has been given the real thing by an electronics store.

Peter Clatworthy, 19, was planning to surprise his four-year-old son with the newly released Microsoft console but received a picture of one instead.

The teenager, from Bilborough, Nottinghamshire, was given a full refund by eBay but still lamented that Christmas wasn’t going to be Christmas without an Xbox One.

But now a CEX outlet in Nottingham has stepped in and gifted him the video games system, which is sold out in the UK."
metro.co.uk/2013/12/09/teenager-scammed-into-buying-450-photo-of-xbox-one-on-ebay-gets-given-real-one-for-free-4223279/

OK, so he was scammed but the listing did say it was for a photo and he received a full refund from eBay. I think that's where this story should have ended. It's gone too far now. He shouldn't be rewarded for making a mistake and a four year old doesn't need an Xbox One! If CEX wanted publicity, they could have donated the console to a charity.

AIBU to think he shouldn't get a free Xbox One for making a mistake and he was trying it on by saying Christmas was ruined because he couldn't get a games console for himself for his four-year-old son?

Madlizzy Tue 10-Dec-13 13:38:44

It's more newsworthy for CEX than a charitable donation though.

NotYoMomma Tue 10-Dec-13 13:39:09

dont be so bloody miserable.

it was nice of them as it was sold out,
they get some publicity
the father and son will be grateful.

admit if it was you you would be delighted that someone did that for you

cantheyseeme Tue 10-Dec-13 13:39:23

Haha just good publicity for CEX really, hes an idiot tbf but the shocking thing of the story.... he is 19 with a 4 year old hmm

sutekidane Tue 10-Dec-13 13:41:10

I think it's a nice gesture. If the console is sold out, his refunded money isn't going to get him one in time for Christmas. It's all for publicity anyway though. CEX will get more attention for this than a donation.

Topaz25 Tue 10-Dec-13 13:41:25

If it was me I would be annoyed at the scammer, annoyed at myself for not reading the listing properly and delighted to receive a refund from eBay. I wouldn't go to the papers with a sob story about how Christmas was ruined because I couldn't get a console.

RedLondonBus Tue 10-Dec-13 13:41:33

its also raising awareness of the dodginess of ebay

you sound bitter op!

sparklysilversequins Tue 10-Dec-13 13:42:05

Yes right, he's 19 and that X Box is definitely for his four year old isn't it? What a load of bollocks.

MmeCinqAnneauxDor Tue 10-Dec-13 13:43:30

I agree with canyouseeme. Good publicity for CEX and I was a bit shocked at him already having a 4yr old at his age.

The Xbox isn't for the 4yr old. It is for daddy, who isn't quite a grown up yet.

LambinsideaDuckinsideaTrout Tue 10-Dec-13 13:44:27

Did you want to get an xbox one or ps4 for your household for xmas but can't seem to find one or what? I agree you sound a little bitter...

thatstoast Tue 10-Dec-13 13:46:19

I hope they throw in a copy Grand Theft Auto 5. That's what all Nineteen four year olds want for Christmas.

JingleMyBells Tue 10-Dec-13 13:46:54

What has this got to do with you OP? Are you annoyed because you want one and they are sold out. I can't see how this affects you in any way.

ZombieMojaveWonderer Tue 10-Dec-13 13:47:40

Haha 'it's for my 4 year old...honest' wink
What a numpty though smile
Nice of cex of course, my 6 year old needs an iPhone 5s....hmmmm wink

Ifcatshadthumbs Tue 10-Dec-13 13:47:56

Oh don't be so miserable. He didn't ask for a freebie and was obviously willing to pay full price when he bought one on eBay.

So what if he wants it for himself? Meh to all you joyless whiners!

HettiePetal Tue 10-Dec-13 13:49:57

I thought Ebay/PayPal (not sure which) refunded him his money?

In the original articles they said they wouldn't tolerate this kind of thing on the site, and that they'd be refunding him and taking action against the seller.

So he gets his money back & another Xbox?

Not that it matters - whoever it was for, that was a particularly nasty scam. I'd have been devastated if it had happened to me.

This does remind me of a Judge Judy ep where someone tried exactly the same thing:

HERE

Ifcatshadthumbs Tue 10-Dec-13 13:50:33

Of course he's not all grown up yet but he's 19 with a 4 year old son.

There's plenty of posters on here complaining about their middle age man child who sits on his arse all day.

ZillionChocolate Tue 10-Dec-13 13:53:33

Could someone please sell me a photo with a yacht parked up at a private Caribbean island please?

WorraLiberty England Tue 10-Dec-13 13:53:38

God how miserable.

I think it's great what CEX did and good luck to the guy.

As for a four year old not needing an XBox one...most four year olds wont actually need half the stuff they'll be bought for Christmas.

Humbug!

HECTheHeraldAngelsSing Tue 10-Dec-13 13:54:38

Well, it retails for £450 but it costs the shop less than that, so they've managed to get loads of free positive pr just before christmas for a few hundred quid.

They haven't given him the console out of the goodness of their hearts grin

And yes, he was a plank. But what the hell? He's benefiting, the shop is benefiting and nobody else is suffering any sort of a financial loss as a result of it, so what's the harm?

Some people are not particularly literate. I haven't seen the ad in question, but perhaps it was misleadingly worded. If ebay gave him his money back, they must surely have felt that it was put in such a way as to be intended to create confusion if your literacy skills are not as good as they could be?

It's certainly going to cost this bloke dear, because if I know people (and I do) he will be mocked mercilessly and he will get all manner of bile spewed at him from various keyboard warriors and a console won't be worth that!

Topaz25 Tue 10-Dec-13 13:55:26

Of course I'm bitter! He was just handed a console worth more than my rent, just for whining in a national paper that his kid's Christmas would be ruined without it. His materialism and sense of entitlement is sickening. He had got a full refund and was still throwing a wobbly like a four year old because he didn't get what he wanted for Christmas. This isn't about Christmas, it isn't about his son, it's about him and now he's got what he wants just for whinging about it. A great lesson to teach his son!

JinglingRexManningDay Tue 10-Dec-13 13:56:18

Is it pronounced Kex or sex? (CEX)

Topaz25 Tue 10-Dec-13 13:57:24

It's pronounced sex, I once had to ring their helpline and had a giggle at that blush

sutekidane Tue 10-Dec-13 13:58:06

How do you even know he actually carried on whinging? He might have been happy with his refund but the CEX shop thought "heeey we're in here!", donated the box and the article was written to make it sound as interesting as possible. PR spin and all that. Wouldn't sound as good if they said "Peter was so happy to get his money back in time for Christmas. Ooh bonus! He got an XBox for free too yay for him!".

Panzee Tue 10-Dec-13 13:58:13

It's true though, innit? The squeaky wheel...

Heartbrokenmum73 Tue 10-Dec-13 13:58:36

Also loving the 19 year-old 4 year-old getting an X Box One for Christmas! Totally appropriate present for a small child - I mean, just look at the big games on that console - COD, GTAV, etc. Just what every self-respecting 4 year-old is into these days grin

Think that bloke's done rather well out of this in the end.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now