Note: Please bear in mind that whilst this topic does canvass opinions, it is not a fight club. You may disagree with other posters but we do ask you please to stick to our Talk Guidelines and to be civil. We don't allow personal attacks or troll-hunting. Do please report any. Thanks, MNHQ.

AIBU or WWYD. Noisy musical instruments in a semi-detached house

(69 Posts)
EightToSixer Mon 11-Nov-13 21:13:46

If your neighbour comes over at 9:05pm to ask you very nicely whether you realise that the clarinet their daughter is playing can be heard very loudly next door and had woken their child up at 6:50am in the morning and 9:05 the same evening, do you:
A) apologise that the noise travelled.
B) ask what time the noise would be a problem and arrange to play at a more reasonable time
C) say, it's not that loud! what do you expect me to do about it?!

eofa1 Mon 11-Nov-13 21:16:20

B)

greenbananas Mon 11-Nov-13 21:16:28

I'd go for a combination of A and B. Good luck.

Wallison Mon 11-Nov-13 21:16:37

This is a reverse AIBU, isn't it? Anyway, I would apologise but tbh the situation shouldn't have arisen - we are a noisy house with lots of instruments but nothing louder than an acoustic guitar gets played before 9 am (11 am on a weekend) or after 9 pm.

treadheavily Mon 11-Nov-13 21:16:47

B

Dobbiesmum Mon 11-Nov-13 21:17:32

B every time. Are you the neighbour? 6.50 is way too early for music practice!! DD is only allowed to practice hers between getting home from school and 7pm. Anytime after 10am on weekends is enough for us (and our neighbours..)!

whois Mon 11-Nov-13 21:17:34

B

This must be a reverse!

Wallison Mon 11-Nov-13 21:17:42

Although I am slightly amazed that a clarinet being played on the other side of a wall is loud enough to wake anyone up - they're really not that loud!

5madthings Mon 11-Nov-13 21:18:04

I would apologize profusely and then do b.

Also make sure the child plkays it away from the party wall. Certainly not upstairs in a bedroom that is ajoined to the neighbours house.

greenbananas Mon 11-Nov-13 21:18:22

Also, is your house set up in such a way that she could play her clarinet in a different room where she is less likely to wake the baby?

tickingboxes Mon 11-Nov-13 21:18:32

B. When my brother had drums the neighbours came round to ask if we could agree times when he could play it. Worked out well.

Snoopingforsoup Mon 11-Nov-13 21:18:34

I would probably apologise and get my child to practice at more sociable hours.
The rule in our home is no instruments after 8:30pm but we live in a terrace with one set of very moany neighbours.
Isn't there a sort of noise law which applies from 11pm to 7am?

greenbananas Mon 11-Nov-13 21:19:44

Mm, you're the neighbour aren't you.... sounds like you have experienced some very unreasonable rudeness!

AutumnWind Mon 11-Nov-13 21:20:15

The problem is it's within reasonable hours (7am-11pm), so not much different to other noise issues.

I would apologise and would try to be aware if neighbour, but it's not always possible. In our house instruments are only ever played in the rooms furthest away from the adjoining wall.

IamInvisible Mon 11-Nov-13 21:20:36

B.

But I bet you asked and they said C!

EeyoreIsh Mon 11-Nov-13 21:21:12

B surely. Can they not play with a mute? I used to practice before school and after, if at music college 3 hours a day is expected.

AutumnWind Mon 11-Nov-13 21:21:40

Sorry, misread earliest time.

The music practice will stop. Better than a cd that can go on indefinitely...

EightToSixer Mon 11-Nov-13 21:24:11

Sorry, yes it's a reverse.
I thought I might be unreasonable for going over there, but they're a pain in the backside. The clarinet being murdered like a screaming cat is plenty loud enough at the wall next to the child's bed.
We have previously had to complain to them for drilling into the party wall of our bedroom at 6:02am on a Sunday morning. The rest of the time we don't complain about their random hours/weird behaviour/general dickishness, so I'm no victor meldrew about it.

I'd rather know about it if it were my child doing it, which is why I nicely asked them to keep it to reasonable hours from now on.

DejaVuAllOverAgain Mon 11-Nov-13 21:28:03

B

Wallison Mon 11-Nov-13 21:30:29

9.05 isn't that unreasonable to be playing music though - put it this way, it's only five minutes after the curfew in this house. And in the morning it's only ten minutes earlier than the time that another poster stated would be classed as a nuisance. It's not as though she's squawking away at 2 or 3 in the morning - it's just evening time, not even really night time. I would put it down to one of those things that happens if you don't have a detached house - I'm sure your own kid makes noise as well!

Fleta Mon 11-Nov-13 21:32:33

Thing is, surely if you're a reasonable person if someone has said to you "we can hear X" you'd make some effort to deal with it - move practice to a different room, do at a different time.

DifferenceEngine Mon 11-Nov-13 21:33:42

D. Buy a drum kit, practice incessantly, but somehow fail to attain any proficiency. smile

IAlwaysThought Mon 11-Nov-13 21:36:39

Wow, they are really, really unreasonable.

I would say after 9 in the morning and before 7. Can they move to a room furthest away from your house.

Mylovelyboy Mon 11-Nov-13 21:36:53

B - I think its fantastic that you are all so musical. But in saying that, would bloody drive me nuts whatever time of day it was to be honest. What gives you the right to inflict your noise on other people.

Mylovelyboy Mon 11-Nov-13 21:39:17

Just re-read. 6.50am - you are taking the piss IMO.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now