Note: Please bear in mind that whilst this topic does canvass opinions, it is not a fight club. You may disagree with other posters but we do ask you please to stick to our Talk Guidelines and to be civil. We don't allow personal attacks or troll-hunting. Do please report any. Thanks, MNHQ.

To not adjust my parenting style because it makes you feel threatened

(87 Posts)
MoltenBlondie Sun 23-Jun-13 19:35:12

I'll start by saying I am nowhere near perfect as a mother, DS is only 18 months and already watches a fair bit of TV, to give one example

But anyway. I have found since he was very little, that if it was discovered that I did something differently to another person (largely MIL, DM and my older sister, but friends too), that they would scoff and try to belittle my choices.

Found it quite upsetting at times but DP has a theory that when I do something differently, it makes them question the way that they parent/ed their children and therefore makes them feel indirectly 'criticised'.

For example DM thinks I'm 'snobby' as I won't let DS have juice in a bottle, DMIL thinks I'm 'mean' for being rigid with bedtimes, Dsis thinks I'm 'controlling' for already insisting DS says 'ta'! and tells me "there's no way you'll have time to be so precious about manners when you have your second" (am currently pg, she has 3)

Why should it bother them so much? Do you think people who do this are genuinely threatened (not even sure that's the right word) by different styles of parenting or after some validation that their own parenting methods were fine?

I should add that I don't volunteer this information, they just witness it when they see me.

probably shouldn't add that I have started to antagonise them a bit now for fun, eg talking to DS loudly about GOING TO BED AT 7, AS THAT'S YOUR BEDTIME EVERY NIGHT, WITHOUT FAIL, ISN'T IT

cantdecideonanewname Mon 24-Jun-13 13:09:49

I said this to my DH in regards to my choice to try and breast feed, neither of our mothers or SIL etc etc breast fed and they seemed to take my decision to breast feed as me insulting the choices they all made. They seemed to take pleasure in my feeding not working out very well too.

They've had/have their babies and did/do it their own way. Keep parenting your child your way.

CecilyP Mon 24-Jun-13 13:11:44

Agreed, RazzleDazzle, two of OPs examples are just different ways of doing things. Neither exactly right or wrong, though I think I have the same negative reaction to 'ta'.

Where juice in a bottle is concerned, OP is 100% right, and perhaps her mum is the one being a snob if she is suggesting only a certain demographic know the effects of juice in a bottle on teeth.

2rebecca Germany Mon 24-Jun-13 13:19:04

My kids said ta when they were toddlers, now they are teenagers they say thanks. They don't talk about moo cows any more either, to me it's just age appropriate language.
I don't think it matters how formal your thank you is as long as you say it. I'd rather my kids said ta than nothing.

fred - it was a joke.

Feminine - it is casual, yes. Perfectly acceptable within normal casual situations (such as within family, or close friends, when someone hands you something etc. not for more formal situations where you might need to use thank you. such as a shop, or a visit etc)

I think this is getting a bit blown out of proportion here
confused

MiaowTheCat Mon 24-Jun-13 14:30:59

Ta as the precursor to thank you when they're old enough - no problem at all. DD1 said it in the correct context for the first time today and it made my morning (then she wouldn't have a nap which un-made it!)

However waffling on about parenting styles - ffs - quit seeking a bloody label and just bloody do it and enjoy your kids without worrying that the rest of the planet's doing it the same way (and that goes for everyone)!

MoltenBlondie Mon 24-Jun-13 14:50:07

Ack, please, I am not a parenting bore! I didn't start by drawing attention to my choices, it was other people's choice to draw attention to them and make me feel like I had to defend myself

And, look, we are not talking about masses of people - just three immediate family members and a couple of friends. Most people, quite rightly, could not give a shit.

But for people here who are claiming I am being over sensitive and seeing criticism where there is none, just look at how many people have had something to say about TA!

I don't bang on about things, i hate labels eg 'attachment', 'blw', I don't stick pictures on my Facebook wall, advertising my choices eg "Harry getting to grips with BLW" or shite like that - as at least three people I know have done!

Elquota Mon 24-Jun-13 16:07:25

> Is "ta" considered a more casual form of "Thank you?"

Yes, it's more casual and perhaps more friendly too. In certain parts of the country it's not in any way unusual for adults to use "ta", to friends, to a shopkeeper or bus driver etc.

MadeOfStarDust Mon 24-Jun-13 16:23:48

Everyone's parenting style is different -

we have never had rigid bedtimes here - too much going on, too much travelling about, too many ill relatives to care for and visit etc.... the kids fit in with our family life... they are 10 and 12 now and can still fall asleep to order...

maybe they think having a rigid bedtime is building up trouble if things do change.. rigid bedtimes can end up meaning a child can't get to sleep easily any other time, so why do it deliberately....

you see..... I sound judgy .... because my way works for me....

LillyGrinter Mon 24-Jun-13 19:07:01

I'm with 'MadeOfStarDust' regarding bedtimes. I aim for 7PM but life often pushes it to a later time and at weekends I get a lie in if DD goes to bed later. I don't give juice at all but still giving milk in a bottle at bedtime and DD started saying Ta at 1 when she started at nursery. One thing I've come to realise is thatParenting is a not an exact science!

chocoluvva Mon 24-Jun-13 23:12:10

Who knew that 'ta' is such a fraught term of thanks? shock

ZiaMaria Tue 25-Jun-13 09:08:54

This has been an education. Ta. smile

We have a routine much like yours OP (though no words yet). Deviation from the routine does occur occasionally, but DD gets a bit cranky so we try to keep it fixed.

You sound like a great mum.

Smithlings Tue 25-Jun-13 10:19:32

I think all your choices sound very sensible, so if you're family are picking at you, it's probably because they know that really and feel a bit guilty/envious. It will wear off in time when they see your children growing up into lovely young people!

Lol Mrs MangoBiscuit - my DD3 is exactly the same - she gets so much praise for her charming manners she works it for all she's worth! They're not stupid!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now