Note: Please bear in mind that whilst this topic does canvass opinions, it is not a fight club. You may disagree with other posters but we do ask you please to stick to our Talk Guidelines and to be civil. We don't allow personal attacks or troll-hunting. Do please report any. Thanks, MNHQ.

To think that this Reverand is rude?

(220 Posts)
PrettyKitty1986 Tue 23-Apr-13 18:22:06

Df thinks IABU but I actually feel quite pissed off ATM.
So-we are getting married next year. We want to get married on a Sunday, in a church that is not our parish church but one that has family connections.
I emailed the Reverand to enquire about the date and ask if he would marry us (we were told by the Parish secretary to email not phone/call in). I got a reply the next day, saying that Sundays were 'not the best day for weddings as the clergy are busy and parishioners who need to attend may have family commitments'. He then went on to ask for details of the qualifying connection that would allow us to marry there so that we could discuss it further.
I emailed back later that day with details of the connection (df's grandparents marrying there) and also asked if there was any time of day we could marry on a Sunday that would be less inconvenient and thus allow us to marry on a Sunday.
I waited for a reply for a full week and nothing.
So, I forwarded the email again, and just said I wanted to check he had received it as I had n't yet had a reply.
He sent an email back saying (word for word) 'I have received your email but it is not quite to the top of my list. Regards'.
That was a week ago...and nothing since.

AIBU to think he's being 'off'? It's now been nearly a month since my first email and we're at risk of losing the provisional booking we have for our venue as we still don't know if he will marry us on that date.

Also, where do I go from here? What can I email him now? Just to stress also, I have been impeccably polite in all emails...I know that marrying in this church is a privelage not a right, but it is very special to df and I really want to be able to marry there for him...so want to move things along but not risk pissing this Reverand off!

Sorry it's long!

ReallyTired Thu 25-Apr-13 22:11:14

Are you sure that you actually have a qualifying connection? Being the grandchild of someone who worshipped at a church is not ususally enough.

Floggingmolly Thu 25-Apr-13 22:02:13

It's not your parish church; and he doesn't want to do a Sunday wedding.
Move on, fgs, and don't be any more pushy than you have been already.

idiot55 Thu 25-Apr-13 21:40:11

he was rude.

He should have said, somehting like, sorry I wouldnt consider a weding on a sunday.........

very rude.

UptheChimney Thu 25-Apr-13 20:30:53

may be he has leave booked

hmm on a Sunday? a priest? grin

Anthracite Thu 25-Apr-13 20:03:32

Reverend is what you put on the outside of an envelope. We should be talking about the vicar or rector.

Whether the vicar agrees to a particular wedding or not is his sole decision. It is not a matter for the PCC.

serin Thu 25-Apr-13 19:59:31

I was married on a Sunday as the Church I had attended from birth (and pretty much every single week thereafter) was already booked on Saturdays for months and months in advance.

I am Catholic and the priest actually suggested the Sunday to us. He knew how much we wanted God to be a focus in our celebration.

LadyMountbatten Thu 25-Apr-13 19:58:24

ITS A VICAR OR PRIEST A REVEREND IS NOT A JOB

greenformica Thu 25-Apr-13 19:35:27

I don't think he was rude. My relative is a Reverend and Sundays are taken up with services/church work with only an hour to eat lunch.

Email again and apologise for pestering him but explain that you are worried you might loose your provisional booking and wondered if he could confirm if the date can go ahead.

I don't know if you mean to OP but you sound very entitled and a bit spoilt.

I think you need to have a good chat with your df. Is that fiance or dad? If he thinks YABU then it's not boding well already. Think of the marriage more than one day.

LadyMountbatten Thu 25-Apr-13 19:20:54

just to say its a VICAR and his title is ReverEND

that is all

* bows and exits*

AnnaBegins Thu 25-Apr-13 19:19:14

YABU. In my last church, the vicar was in charge of 7 parishes. Yes 7. So you can imagine how busy Sundays were.

FWIW, we got married in a church outside of our parish, but it was my regular place of worship and where I'd grown up. It still went to discussion within the PCC though as we were out of parish.

Maybe if you were regular worshippers at the church you want to be married in then the vicar would be more inclined to accommodate you, and you would also know what he's like and whether he has a tendency to be short in emails/really busy at certain times.

Still wouldn't expect a Sunday wedding though!

Also, a wedding a month is seriously busy! My old church planned for 7-8 a year! And that was the largest, prettiest church in the group of 7 so the most popular.

givemeaclue Thu 25-Apr-13 18:41:51

Do you have an alternative op? Think you need to go with plan b.

Also wouldn't have the wedding on a Sunday

JamieandtheMagicTorch Thu 25-Apr-13 18:26:58

This is quite funny.

I think your ignorance has annoyed him.

phantomnamechanger Thu 25-Apr-13 18:04:29

child of a vicar here - well said revness and others with similar arguements/reasonings

I love this sentence too -
However, despite the myth, vicars do not only work on Sundays, and they are neither superhuman nor superheroes, you're mistaking us for Jesus himself

.....the number of times i was asked by schoolfriends, "so what does your dad do for a real job, you know, apart from on Sundays"

hahahahahaha!

DeskPlanner Thu 25-Apr-13 17:34:27

Ah. sorry La, I understand you now.

Bue - do you realise that the vicar's reasons for not wanting to marry the OP on a Sunday might include the fact that it is already his busiest day of the week? He might have several services that day, either in that church or in several churches, if he serves more than one parish, as many do, and might not want to cram a wedding into the middle of all that, and do a rushed service for the OP and her groom. And he might want to have a little bit of time to himself to - oh, I don't know - eat lunch or spend a bit of time with his family.

You are right that there is no hard and fast rule that people cannot be married on a Sunday - but there are a lot of very good reasons why it only happens rarely - and then only with the vicar's cooperation and agreement!

The OP has clearly not bothered to book the church (which should be the most important part of the whole day), or even check that she could get married on the day she wanted, before going ahead and booking the reception venue. That was not a sensible thing to do, and it has come back to bite her on the bum. That's not the vicar's fault.

LaVolcan Thu 25-Apr-13 15:52:04

DeskPlanner We don't get many marriages because most of the congregation are getting on a bit. We still get sons and daughters of members marrying there although they have quite often moved away and marry nearer to home.

What I meant was that we don't get the people who have no connection with church but want a pretty building.

DeskPlanner Thu 25-Apr-13 14:39:15

Yes, op+, if you do come back, I would be interested to know why a Sunday at all. Aren't people In work the next day ?

DeskPlanner Thu 25-Apr-13 14:35:14

La, I think that's a bit sad. People who attend church on a regular basis are part on that churches family, they should want to marry there. Not be put off because its not 'pretty'. That's not what a church wedding should be about.

Still18atheart Thu 25-Apr-13 14:33:53

YABU

The excuse Sunday is not the best day, is way to tell someone no but in a letting down gently type of way. That's a applicable in any situation especially this one.

I agree with whoever it was who said that your df should have emailed the reverend, and told a lovely story about growing up in the parish and recall some events which happened at the the church which he attended.

Also agree with everyone who has said that the reception will be a bit flat as everyone will be concentrating on work the next day.

Bue Thu 25-Apr-13 14:32:23

Where have people got the idea that the CofE doesn't marry anyone on a Sunday? It's not a rule.

www.yourchurchwedding.org/faqs/may-we-marry-on-a-sunday.aspx

OP your reasons for wanting to get married there sound totally legitimate, it sounds like a very important place in your DF's family history. The vicar probably just doesn't want to marry you on a Sunday for his own reasons. And yes, I think he sounds rude.

DeskPlanner Thu 25-Apr-13 14:31:09

I totally agree with Voice, being married in church should not be about the dream of the big white wedding. If your not religious, then just find another pretty building. The op may attend church every week for all I know, so I'm not talking about her, just in general.

LaVolcan Thu 25-Apr-13 13:56:40

Believe in God, get married in church. Don't believe in God, then go for stately home, hotel, registrar's office, Gretna Green etc.

One clergyman's wife told me that the number of weddings dropped off dramatically in her church once venues such as stately homes were licensed.

I go to a church which doesn't score particularly highly on the attraction stakes i.e. not the pretty village church, nor the ornate pile in the town centre with lots of stained glass, and we don't do many weddings at all, and they nearly all have some sort of connection with the church.

Be easier all round if churches made a hard and fast rule only to marry people who were born in that parish or have attended that particular church for a specified period of time (and I don't mean once a month for six months).

People are quite happy to marry in church even though they have no connection at all or, very often, religious beliefs. I know many women who when they marry want a big white wedding in church even though they don't believe in God. In which case, it's all about the show. Which isn't what it should be about.

Believe in God, get married in church. Don't believe in God, then go for stately home, hotel, registrar's office, Gretna Green etc.

limitedperiodonly Thu 25-Apr-13 13:22:21

I thought it was rude. I must be being a bit sensitive, which is rare for me.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now