to be angry at facebook response

(46 Posts)
brummiegirl1 Thu 18-Apr-13 18:48:22

I reported a photo on facebook that i saw on facebook. It is a photo of men around a music deck outside. The slogan says "hold on bitch, i need to drop the bass" and the man is pushing the woman's face away.
I found it very bad taste and aggressive towards women. I know it's meant to be a joke but i don't see how that can be funny.

I have just got a respose back from facebook saying that the picture will not be removed

Thanks for your report. We reviewed the photo you reported, but found it doesn't violate Facebook's Community Standard on graphic violence, which includes depicting harm to someone or something, threats to the public's safety, or theft and vandalism.

I complained about it under the violence category as there were no other appropriate headings. I replied saying i was not happy as how can they class a photo where a woman is called a "BITCH" and pushed in the face acceptable?

Sorry but feel so mad with it.

TheRealFellatio Thu 18-Apr-13 18:51:26

YANBU. For some bizarre reason there seems to be something about popular culture that centres around certain kinds of music that has set sexual equality back by about a hundred years. It makes me sick, and I don't even call myself a feminist.

valiumredhead Thu 18-Apr-13 18:51:37

I have deactivated my account - I have been FB free for over 2 weeks and I feel freeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!! grin

DearJohnLoveSavannah Thu 18-Apr-13 18:53:01

I sometimes wonder how people leave the house when they get offended by such trivial things.

I'm sorry that this has caused you anger and offensive, but life really is too short. Just hide it instead of reporting it next time.

Tee2072 Thu 18-Apr-13 18:54:42

You should find the recent article written by a FB mod. You'll never bother them for something so trivial again.

YANBU. that's their response to reports of violence against women.

I got an 'extra' email from them the other day asking if I was satisfied with their response to a report I made about a page crawling with misogynistic shite and comments verging on child abuse.
I said I was certainly not happy with their refusal to do anything about the page or its posts.

Not that they give a shit, obviously.

CajaDeLaMemoria Thu 18-Apr-13 18:55:36

Facebook is absolutely covered in pages that glorify rape, trying to cause women to miscarry, domestic violence, etc.

They will not remove them, regardless of how many times they are reported, unless their advertisers complain.

That tells you everything you need to know about Facebook. They play for profit, and you've got no chance of getting the image removed. It sounds positively mild compared to some of the atrocious things I've seen on there.

SarahAndFuck Thu 18-Apr-13 18:56:51

Facebook do not care.

I reported an image of a man pushing a woman head first down the stairs, it captured her mid fall and in mid air, with the caption "Next time don't get pregnant" on it and Facebook decided that this was alternative humour rather than graphic violence.

brummiegirl1 Thu 18-Apr-13 18:57:58

I didn't know you could hide things on facebook. It's not a case of being offended about trivial things (even though i don't think it is trivial as it sends a message that it's ok to talk about women in that manner) it's the fact they think its acceptable to leave it up.

HeadFairy Thu 18-Apr-13 18:59:46

Get in touch with Everyday Sexism. They're running a campaign to get advertisers to stop advertising with FB because their ads often appear alongside pages depicting violence against women and FB won't guarantee where they put ads. It's quite a high profile campaign, if you're on Twitter, they're on @everydaysexism

Someone on MN posted this the other day. (I can't remember who it was now, but thank you I have forwarded it on to a few people now) Its well worth a read and it might make you think twice before reporting things that you find offensive but you could really just hide and forget about.

imour Thu 18-Apr-13 19:03:32

facebook is full of `joke` pictures , people find different things funny or offensive ,you cant please everyone , lifes too short to get wound up over a picture .

brummiegirl1 Thu 18-Apr-13 19:05:26

thanks headFairy i will look at that.

Tommy Thu 18-Apr-13 19:06:37

wow - that article is something else isn't it sad

Just delete whichever dickhead shared the photo in the first place... Then breathe.

Tee2072 Thu 18-Apr-13 19:11:07

Thanks Missy that's the article I couldn't find.

Oops I didn't see that it had been mentioned blush sorry Tee

It really does give a different outlook to the things that people should be reporting. sad

I should probably say THE LINK I POSTED ABOVE COULD BE A TRIGGER FOR SOME PEOPLE, IT CONTAINS SOME DETAILS OF CHILD ABUSE

Skiffle Thu 18-Apr-13 19:57:08

What a weird article MissyMoo. I can see why it's an awful job being that facebook person (people) but how bizarre to blame people for complaining about things they see to Facebook, it's not like they're ringing 999 to complain is it. And saying "X is so much worse than Y" doesn't mean we should still ignore Y (not directing that are you Missy, just at the writer).

Skiffle Thu 18-Apr-13 19:57:33

sorry meant at you not are you

I see what you are saying Skiffle but I think that a lot of the things reported on FB is just down to what different people find funny, in which case just delete the person sharing it or block the picture there is no need for a lot of it to be censored.

I also didn't realise until I read that that the FB moderators are often dealing with crimes in progress or that are about to be committed so it is a bit like 1000 people calling 999 because someone gave them a funny look and there being genuine emergencies slipping through the net because of it.

Surely its better to try and educate the people sharing the odd sexist or offensive picture than to just censor it and have them still hold their views unchallenged anyway?

Skiffle Thu 18-Apr-13 20:20:52

MissyMoo I agree with you that the reports mentioned in the article are a waste of time, honestly who complains because they don't like the look of a fish. But the things mentioned higher up in this thread I wouldn't consider a waste of time at all, pictures of and incitement to violence should not be allowed on Facebook and indeed they claim it isn't, but clearly that's not the case.

The problem is Facebook has no actual responsibility - it's a commercial organisation not a public service. If the shareholders actually cared, they would employ many more people to deal with the complaints so that they could deal with them appropriately and respond to crimes if necessary. But clearly they couldn't care less, the same as any other large profit making organisation.

Also, surely it takes hardly any more time to block a truly offensive picture than to send an email to the complainer saying it doesn't breach the guidelines. They just don't care.

YouDontWinFriendsWithSalad Thu 18-Apr-13 20:21:17

My god that article is sobering. After reading that I'm going to have to say YABU, OP, but I do empathise with your annoyance, definitely.

I just googled the picture the OP was talking about, and tbh, it could be someone messing about, it could be violent, or it could be set up, FB are right that it doesn't depict graphic violence and it is a big possibility that it doesn't depict violence at all.

I don't really know how it works with regards to sending emails out, I would imagine it would just be a quick click, put them all into a folder then send a mass email out rather than actual individual replies. They probably get thousands of reports about the same things per day so they wouldn't have to look a lot of the time.

With some pictures there would be no arguement that they are offensive and they would be removed, with others it is just down to levels of tolerence and FB are pretty careful about censorship from what I know of them (which admittedly isn't that much because I'm not on it).

I agree with the sentiment of the article though, if you can't handle people saying the odd thing you may find offensive then FB isn't the place for you it has millions of people on it who will all have a different sense of humour so imo if it isn't illegal then it shouldn't really be censored however much I disagree with some of the things I have read about being on there.

DaffodilAdams Thu 18-Apr-13 21:07:57

That article is shit. It is not an excuse to leave up threats of violence against women, threats of rape etc because there is worse out there. They seem to manage to find time (and apparent concern) to remove photos of women breast feeding or women showing a nipple or women protesting against the misogyny shown to them, but not pages inciting child abuse or rape.

OP YANBU

OkayHazel Thu 18-Apr-13 21:48:29

Facebook is like a mother in law... smile and nod, and get on with your life.

Block/hide who and what you don't want to see.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now