Note: Please bear in mind that whilst this topic does canvass opinions, it is not a fight club. You may disagree with other posters but we do ask you please to stick to our Talk Guidelines and to be civil. We don't allow personal attacks or troll-hunting. Do please report any. Thanks, MNHQ.

To ask if you would give your nearly 7 month old chocolate?

(114 Posts)

Actual chocolate, not like a jar of chocolate baby pudding. I'm talking chocolate buttons for Easter etc.

confused
I'm just feeling pressured into it right now, and I don't want to but am I being a PFB mother?

JenaiMorris Tue 02-Apr-13 07:09:25

What do people think will happen if a 7mo eats a few chocolate buttons? confused

Each to their own, but just as babies don't need chocolate, nor do they need shielding from it (allergies etc excepted).

BippyB Mon 01-Apr-13 23:10:57

Exactly toysrluv. When our lad is old enough to ask for things like that we will let him try them and do so without comment either negative or positive. He has had the odd bit of cake or crisp whenever he has been in reaching distance of them but not gone mad for them and I didn't make a fuss about it, as he would pick up on that too.

Probably the best influence in your child's life is your own eating habits. If you don't gorge on chocolate and biscuits and don't have them in the house as a matter of course, then your kids will come to see that as normal, and view them as an occasional treat.

However as per the OP's query, at 7 months I think it's wrong wrong wrong.

olivertheoctopus Mon 01-Apr-13 23:02:33

I wouldn't give them 4 whole Easter eggs but I don't buy into this whole 'no choc/sweets til they are x age' shit. My 4yo DS actively dislikes chocolate. Weirdo. I eat his eggs...

samlamb Mon 01-Apr-13 22:57:12

IsabelleRinging I'm TOTALY with you.

ToysRLuv Mon 01-Apr-13 22:36:15

Btw, in my later post I'm obviously not referring to 6 months olds specifically, but making a wider point.

aldiwhore Mon 01-Apr-13 22:34:44

YANBU at all.

But I did give mine a button or two at that age and it did not harm them in the slightest. IWNBU either.

I am not liking the language they use towards you. Utterly disrespectful. Any way you can move far away from their toxicity? They sound far more damaging than chocolate buttons.

ToysRLuv Mon 01-Apr-13 22:33:13

Have to add that I was largely denied sweets in my childhood (later my mum said that she was concerned about my dental health, etc.) and I can see how it contributed towards my eating disorders in later life. I know some others with the same history and problems, so I would be very wary of overly restricting sweets etc. It is a normal human craving, and nothing to be ashamed of. If denied, it can with some people become an obsession..

I would say everything's fine in moderation and occasional days of OTT chocolate are fine, as well (and fondly remembered by DH, who's a healthy eater, from his childhood).

YANBU - your baby, your choice. Although I let DD (6 months) have a chocolate button yesterday as I was eating chocolate - she wasn't impressed - prefers broccoli! tiny weirdo

ToysRLuv Mon 01-Apr-13 22:24:55

Like some others on this thread, I gave DS whatever we ate from 6 months old (BLW). Bits of choc and cake as well as broccoli and peach.

It is in our biology to enjoy sweet foods (for babies even more so), and I can only imagine that the (evil?) people who are gifting choc eggs to 6 month olds want to give the babies they love the wonderful feeling and experience of chocolate melting in their mouths (even if it's just a tiny bit at a time). If you do not want to give your baby chocolate - don't. Say no thanks or eat it yourself. It's like with any unwanted gift, I guess.

NumericalMum Mon 01-Apr-13 22:01:48

I was so pleased my DC was dairy intolerant and would have thrown it all up and I would have gone crazy when these things came up. Mil and my DM would have happily force fed her all sorts of shite behind my back. Now she is 5 and gorged herself yesterday but mostly has a sensible attitude to all food. She tries new foods and is superbly active and healthy. Moderation is key to everything.

GummyAdams Mon 01-Apr-13 22:00:52

Although I was cross at the woman feeding DS chocolate, I've just remembered telling another Mum that DS had had a lick of a dark chocolate bar that I was eating. He had just been weaned at 6 months, was trying to sample everything, so I thought what the heck and let him gum it very briefly.
Fuck me, what a catsbumface. You'd have thought I'd said I was mixing nutella and haribo into his morning porridge.

So OP, you can't winwink

Sparklyboots Mon 01-Apr-13 21:56:31

We haven't given DS (2.3) any 'straight' chocolate yet, though he has had a taste of hot chocolate and a bit of chocolate cake at parties. We were tres strict about all processed food right through til 18/mo 2yr because it takes that long for a gut to mature and we saw no harm in taking it slow. He's very adventurous and will try anything we're having - the strictness was easy because DP and I are boring health conscious so don't eat processed sugar, super-refined carbs etc. Now he's a bit bigger and food is becoming a more important part of his social experience we are quite relaxed so happy for him to have cake and so on, but haven't changed what we buy for home, so it's all quite whole-food lentil weavery type stuff at home.

That said, chocolate is still off the menu because it contains caffeine and another stimulant (I think it's called theo-bromeine or similar) in large enough quantities that if you gave a race horse a mars bar, it'd show up on a doping test. My line about this to anyone offering him chocolate is that he doesn't need any extra stimulation, though I should confess that it is pleasing to turn down a food which is really nutritionally crap in general terms (they are NEVER offering the much touted 'two or three squares of quality chocolate' which are supposed to be good for us, IME).

Obvs this doesn't go down brilliantly with everyone and I particularly get written off as uptight (which irritates slightly as DP has exactly the same view) but I couldn't give a fuck, TBH. The only people who are bothered by it are people who have a problem themselves - they are either so caught up in the 'treat' idea about food that they think DS is somehow 'deprived' (which always makes me think they really should widen their ideas about both 'treats' and 'deprivation') or they are trying to 'buy' DS's affection/ approval (which I find slightly sad and misguided).

We used to experience more tension from others around this than we do now - no one even bothered to ask about whether he was 'allowed' an Easter Egg this year, and no one bought him an egg. We were at friends for Easter lunch and an egg was sitting on the table for people to help themselves to. DS didn't even recognise it as food, so there was no awkward moment. Stick to your guns, OP, and don't let anyone see you get wound up about it- treat your boundaries like they are facts of life and not up for negotiation and people soon look for something else to criticise your parenting for just give up and move on.

BippyB Mon 01-Apr-13 21:29:39

Stand your ground! My lad is 21 months now and for the second Easter running I still refuse to give him chocolate. My view is that he's not even old enough to really know what it is or ask for it, so why would I give it to him? Sugar will do him no good AT ALL. It's my decision and as far as I'm concerned everyone else can respect my wishes.

What really gets my goat is that that mothers get flak for everything they do wrong, yet when you take a decision which is purely for your own child's good, people seem determined to see it as something else. If I had a pound for every minute I'd had to spend politely listening to relatives and friends telling me it "won't do any harm" to give my child chocolate, cake, sweets, etc. I'd be a rich woman. Maybe it won't do any harm (oh, apart from rotting his teeth, which are blooming difficult to clean properly in a 21 month old) but on the other hand, items like chocolate, mini rolls, etc won't do your child ANY GOOD either. So why would you give them stuff like that before they are old enough to even ask?

Only today I had a relative round with a richly iced coffee cake (FFS!) saying "oh well he can have a little bit, can't he?" My answer was, NO. I'm sure some people think I'm an extremist but don't give in, when your own instincts (and NHS advice) is not to give your child unnecessary sugar at that age.

BadRoly Mon 01-Apr-13 21:26:44

Dc1 - no absolutely not. No chocolate until well after 1st birthday
Can't honestly remember with dc2 & 3
Dc4 - was past caring, probably dc1, 2 & 3 had been feeding him chocolate from hours old (joking obviously but you get my point wink). Almost certainly he'd had a chocolate button or 2 by 7mths as he was given whatever we were eating to eat.

BinksToEnlightenment Mon 01-Apr-13 21:20:23

You'll muddle through. Best thing to remember with a baby is don't sweat the small stuff.

Now no asking us what we think of the situation in Syria or bedroom tax! grin

Thank you! I thought my NN could be a bit of a clue to me being clueless wink

Theicingontop Mon 01-Apr-13 21:10:46

Did think it was a bit of an odd thing to go undercover for grin

BinksToEnlightenment Mon 01-Apr-13 21:10:38

I don't think you're a journalist, op. It's hardly article worthy news anyway is it! 'Mums divided on Easter chocolate issue'.

Mumsyblouse Mon 01-Apr-13 21:05:32

I don't think you should give anything you don't want to, but all this holding out til aged 11 months or whatever is pointless in the long run. I remember my cousins' mum doing exactly the same, no sugar at all at the grandparent's house, no easter treats even til age about three, it was all a big fuss and very earnest (no jam, etc) My cousins are now in their late twenties and eat like everyone else does! My mum was very restrictive around food, again only a few tiny sweets once a week, and unfortunately I am a sweet scoffer now- thirty years later.

Nothing wrong with trying to keep children away from chocolate as long as you realise you can't turn the tide in the end. They will grow up, they will make their own choices, and forbidden fruit is often the sweetest.

Sorry if I worded it wrong. blush
I've a long running thread here on OTBT. I'm did a NC at Christmas. If you'd like to think I'm a journo feel free, I'm a 23 year old first time single mum seeking some guidence that was all, I shouldn't have to justify that, just because I tried to be polite to people 'participating' on a thread when I'm sure they had better things to do with their time than help me. sad

"than you for participating"
okaaaay

maddy68 Mon 01-Apr-13 20:59:41

A bit of chocolate Won't do a 7 month old any harm. Just going do it too often x

I'm not a journo or anything! I'm a genuine MNetter!
Research my history if you like, I was just being polite for people for taking the effort to reply confused

RubyGates Mon 01-Apr-13 20:57:48

I think DS2 was about that age for his first Easter, I encouraged his relatives to buy him eggs, gave him a couple of chocolate buttons to enter into the spirit of the thing. And then ate the rest myself. grin
Win/win

Theicingontop Mon 01-Apr-13 20:56:17

Oh dear, really?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now