AIBU to veto tacky merchandise?

(67 Posts)
abbyfromoz Sat 30-Mar-13 22:13:54

DD is almost 2 and is starting to get really keen on Peppa Pig. Everywhere we go we hear 'Pebig!!! Pebig!!'
I don't mind her watching it.
I know she would ADORE wearing Peppa P.J's or eating on a Peppa plate- cuddling a Peppa doll or wearing a Peppa backpack- but it makes me cringe with the tackiness of it.
I feel quite mean but I don't know what it is- i just really can't stand tat.
she has plenty of (mostly) wooden toys or nice looking ones eg, schleich, heimess or brio...and loves her drawing easel
I also don't like anything with a slogan or motif (eg. 'Here comes trouble') puke.
Am i depriving her? Or does anyone agree with me?

Maryz Sun 31-Mar-13 12:06:05

Gosh, you sound lovely shock

I wasn't calling you a snob, and for what it's worth anyone who says you are snobby for your posts isn't attacking you; they are saying you are snobby about toys. Which you are. It's a statement of fact, not a personal attack.

And anyway, I was simply saying that when you have a 2 year old it is quite normal to think you can have "tasteful" toys.

Come back in five years; I doubt very much your house won't be full of tacky crap.

JambalayaCodfishPie Sun 31-Mar-13 12:08:33

Aibu? Yes.

NO IM NOT!!!

StuntGirl Sun 31-Mar-13 12:09:10

Why start an AIBU when you're so adamant you're not?

Really op wanted everyone to say "gosh, you're right, how dreadfully tacky" not YABU

BruthasTortoise Sun 31-Mar-13 12:12:39

I think the fact that you're not only referring to toys makes your OP sound quite "snobbish". Surely a back pack is a back pack and if your DD wants a Peppa Pig then why shouldn't she have one (obviously assuming she needs a backpack of some shape, sort or description)? It seems from that that you're putting aesthetics ahead of your DDs happiness. My DS loves a Happy Meal cuddly he got on a rare trip to McDs, he brings it everywhere with him, if he was your DD would you take it off her because it didn't suit your taste?

abbyfromoz Sun 31-Mar-13 12:13:22

I am lovely Mary smile i will take your (assumed sarcasm) as a compliment as I don't think it's wise to sum up a person based on a simple AIBU thread.
I guess i am being a little 'snobby about toys' as opposed to being a snob... I'm sure i can live with that though wink
Happy Easter!

Maryz Sun 31-Mar-13 12:16:41

No, I'm making my assumption on your last couple of posts. Which include the words "Nice", "Clever" and "Oh please".

All presumably used with a tad of sarcasm.

Which makes you sound, quite frankly, not very nice (no sarcasm there at all).

Sirzy Sun 31-Mar-13 12:17:08

Having "tat" doesn't stop children being creative or playing outdoors you know!

Viviennemary Sun 31-Mar-13 12:20:19

My Mum was like this. Even if I got money as a birthday present and wanted to spend it on something she considered tat she usually wouldn't let me unless I made a horrendous fuss. blush So I usually tried to let mine have what they wanted at Christmas. Furbies anyone. That was the biggest waste of money ever.

abbyfromoz Sun 31-Mar-13 12:20:22

I have taken on board a lot of the (genuine and non critical) advice-

I guess knowing so many people value tacky crap as a necessary part of childhood is helpful in that I will be more prepared for what is ahead!
And i will be more open to some of these toys knowing it is inevitable...

Again- have a happy (non tacky grin) Easter all

Mooshbag Sun 31-Mar-13 12:48:09

I think it's more that we value the happiness of our DCs rather than valuing tacky crap. And no one said they had to have everything

EeyoresGloomyPlace Sun 31-Mar-13 16:01:22

I think you're being a bit sensitive OP. I said you were being a snob in relation to the toys, not as a personal attack. I am sometimes a bit snobbish about things too, but I have tried for DDs sake not to be restrictive of things she would "adore".

She's only young and children don't need a huge abundance of toys, so you do have a level of control in that of course you shouldn't give in to her wanting every piece of characterised or plastic tat she sees, but on the flip side there really is no harm in a few bits and pieces that don't fit in with your ideal and as she gets older you will have less control so its probably for the best to accept that now!

steppemum Tue 02-Apr-13 02:01:28

What you will find is that you have no control over some things. So I have avoided backpacks with characters on, especially sparkly pink ones. Then dd2 got given a Tinkerbell backpack. She will not be parted from it and she instantly became an huge Tinkerbell fan, even though she has no idea who Tinkerbell is, and has never seen the film.

My only consolation is that it isn't pink, and is quite a pretty colour. So I could have hidden the backpack and refused to buy anything with Tinkerbell on it, but instead I let her get on with it, and decided it wasn't a battle worth fighting, and she chose a Tinkerbell lunchbox for school.

You make an interesting connection though that all character mechandise it plastic crap and that all plastic crap is character related.

In fact dd2 has a very nice wooden dolls house with wooden furniture. Instead of buying dollhouse dolls, we bought the peppa pig figures on the internet. It is referred to as the 'Peppa Pig House' and she has played with it solidly for 2 years and it has been the source of much creative and imaginative play. By a little creativity ourselves, we have the best of both worlds.

Buy a nice looking basket for all her 'treasures' and then they will be well hidden! grin

MusicalEndorphins Tue 02-Apr-13 05:10:37

You can have homemade Peppa Pig dolls and cardigans and so on if you can knit or sew. This doll would be good for your dd's age.

pigletmania Tue 02-Apr-13 07:07:46

Yabu life's too short, she's a child so let her be one. She's too young to understand your reasoning and politics. Get her son peppy pig stuff if tats what she would like. Wooden toys are great but not for every Chidren mabey your dd wants a mixture

Rosa Tue 02-Apr-13 07:19:18

It up to you however if you says she would adore something ...would you not get imense joy seeing her so happy? I know I do. BTW mine have cheap £1 snack boxes with Hello Kitty on. DD1 uses hers daily for school, tupperware one used the previous year lasted about 10 mths Hello Kitty is still going strong!!

maddening Tue 02-Apr-13 07:21:56

Ds loves peppa pig - we got a peppa pig bundle on ebay for £25 (rocket, boat, playground sets, school set, train, camper van and lots of figures) and he has the peppa pig house - he plays with the figures (loves dolls houses and the peppa pig house is smaller for our tiny cottage)

He has a peppa pig pencil case also.

I say go with it smile

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now