to find myself shouting IT'S NOT ABOUT THE HORSE MEAT

(171 Posts)
ICBINEG Fri 08-Feb-13 12:22:37

It's about companies not having the faintest idea what is in the food they sell!

Drugs, contaminants, carcinogens, allergens etc.

If you don't even know it is horse not beef then how can I trust it doesn't contain milk and hence will not kill my DNephew if I happen to feed it to him?

The same goes for toys. If you don't know who actually made the parts and from what then how do you know it isn't smothered in lead/anything else that is extremely harmful to children?

I predict a future filled with product and toy recalls followed by lawsuits until retailers wake up to the fact that we WILL blame them when a burger/toy they sold us harms the health of our children.

Heard on the beeb earlier that apparently Romania passed a law a few months ago banning horse and carts from the roads, which caused a massive influx of horses in slaughter houses.

And to me, actually, it is about the horse.

<weeps quietly>

mrsbunnylove Sat 09-Feb-13 23:20:36

its not about the horse. for goodness sake, eat the horse.
its about the lies. don't charge me for beef if i'm getting horse. don't tell me its beef when i'm getting horse.
and exactly where are they getting the horse? horse farms? old horses from wherever they go nowadays?

i haven't eaten beef (knowingly) since 1988. i'm just waiting to hear that the chicken i've been feasting on is actually dog.

amillionyears Sat 09-Feb-13 22:43:19

My DH muttered something about McDonalds meat being ok as the source is ok apparently?

ivykaty44 Sat 09-Feb-13 22:38:52

not sure how much meat you would get from a cat - but surely it must be as much as a chicken - around 1.5kg would be a sunday dinner and roughly 3ilb of meat for a family of four.

But how much meat you get from one cat isn't the point is it as it would probably be used for things like chicken nuggets or lasagna where they don't use a great deal of meat in any case.

Has mcdonalds been tested to see if there irish beef is really beef as the Irish horse meat burgers were not beef

YADNBU! Was talking to my boss about this yesterday. Will read the thread properly now grin

amillionyears Sat 09-Feb-13 13:31:47

What about fish Maryz?

I cringe when I feed my goldfish, fishfood.
Seems all wrong.

amillionyears Sat 09-Feb-13 13:30:22

Maryz grin
Not thought of things in that way before!

amillionyears Sat 09-Feb-13 13:29:30

It was like that with financial scandals.
The people supposedly keeping an eye on things, are, quite frankly, not up to the job.
[in that case, apparantly, the people overlooking the financial industry are not so bright as the finance people, and that is where they end up, if they are not so bright]

amillionyears Sat 09-Feb-13 13:26:56

What bothers me the most, Lady, is what the Food Standards Agency are doing?
Isnt that why they exist? To test our food, or to test the supermarket testers?

I have long since given up believing that we know exactly what is in our food, correct labelling or not correct labelling.
I am well aware that there are unscrupulous people out there putting things in our food that shouldnt be there.

But where are the testers?

Maryz Sat 09-Feb-13 13:18:33

See, guinea pigs are herbivores, like rabbits, so if you eat rabbit why not guineapig?

I wouldn't eat carnivores, which rules out cats and dogs.

Though pigs are omnivores, aren't they <ponders> and I do like a bacon sarnie confused

LadyIsabellaWrotham Sat 09-Feb-13 13:11:29

YANBU. If I thought that moustache-twirling Findus execs were saying "Ooh, horse meat is cheaper than beef, let's put that in our lasagne, no one will notice" then I'd be cross, but not scared. It's the fact that they didn't know that scares me.

amillionyears Sat 09-Feb-13 13:06:43

I have been itching to say guinea pig anybody?!

Didnt realise anybody would eat it.

The other horsemeat thread I am currently on, a poster says lots of people are not bothered about horse.

And I think they eat rats in China?

So maybe to some, meat is meat.

[have been wondering what I would knowingly eat tbh]

Think I wouldnt eat guineapig.

Though I guess if you are very hungry, you would eat just about anything that is put in front of you.

Maryz Sat 09-Feb-13 13:02:25

I think ivykaty means meat from cats, amillion, not food for cats.

I wouldn't have thought there was enough meat on most cats to make a meal. Though apparently guinea pig is a luxury food in some countries.

amillionyears Sat 09-Feb-13 13:00:35

which paper ivykaty44?

I was on a thread where most posters it seems use the same utensils for their pet food as human food. And couldnt see the problem. And said that pet food is fit for human consuption.

That was 1 week before the recent food scandals erupted.

aamia Sat 09-Feb-13 12:53:06

I'm sure they DID know - or someone along the line did. A nice cost cutting measure there, and I bet those were the horses that are sent to market 'not fit for human consumption' due to the drugs they have received shortly before death. Nice.

So glad we get our meat from the butchers, where they receive half a cow/pig etc, KNOW what it is (and usually from which farm it came from), and cut it up in the shop to be sold!

ivykaty44 Sat 09-Feb-13 11:32:51

there is something in the papers this morning about cat meat - is this correct has anyone else seen about cat meat? I can't re find the article

mercibucket Fri 08-Feb-13 22:21:01

just thinking of the china baby milk scandal too sad

piprabbit Fri 08-Feb-13 22:17:58

I don't know if anyone remembers the awful situation in China a few years ago. Criminals were selling adulterated baby milk, and many babies starved because their milk contained nothing of nutritional value - these were well fed (seemingly), well cared for, loved children.

I thought that something like that could never happen here. Now I am less sure.

Bogeyface Fri 08-Feb-13 22:17:28

I agree that the issue is about the fact that they are not sure what is in the food, which as you say, can cause serious issues for some. My cousins kids are severely allergic to several things, they could die if something is in their food that shouldnt be. Its not about not wanting to eat horse meat.

However, I did have an argument with my dad about it as he doesnt agree that there is no moral difference between eating horse, and eating cow, or pig, or dog or hamster come to that! I am not a veggie, but I rarely eat meat and I dont think that I can kick up a stink about one animal dying to feed me and not another.

ConferencePear Fri 08-Feb-13 22:13:29

I anyone thinks it's just about it being horsemeat, tell them that Findus lasagne, cottage pie and moussaka have been taken of the shelves in French supermarkets.

Ooh begonia good point. Eew, are they testing for human DNA (glad I buy very little processed food. I'll try not to think about my mafia funded salami!)

giveitago Fri 08-Feb-13 20:03:55

But it is also about horse meat. I've been offered and refused because I don't want it. But it's in other stuff.

I think these companies are aware of what they are getting actually.

AllYoursBabooshka Fri 08-Feb-13 20:00:18

I found myself squeaking the same thing in outrage at my dad today.

"Yes dad, we know you would try anything that has a mother BUT IT'S NOT ABOUT THE HORSE MEAT"

Sigh.

BegoniaBampot Fri 08-Feb-13 19:53:31

Heard in the news earlier that they think the horse meat came from a criminal element. What the hell could be in our food if criminal gangs are actually at the source, we could be eating anything.

piprabbit Fri 08-Feb-13 17:34:30

If the supermarkets want to sell me horsemeat, fair enough. But at least have the decency to label it as such and not pretend it is 100% beef, so that I can choose whether to eat it.

If you don't know you are selling horsemeat, how can you possibly guarantee it is not contaminated?

In the past, food scares have tended to be all about the the UK supply chain. It turns out that the UK is only a tiny part of the issue.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now