My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

To think my dad is a complete twat. Long sorry!

21 replies

SacreLao · 06/11/2011 01:14

Background: I am the oldest of 3 children. I have 2 DC and am expecting number 3, younger sis has 3 DC and younger brother has none (only 19 years old). We all have partner's that we live with, I am in a same-sex relationship that my dad disapproves of. All in a similar financial situation, not exactly rich but not exactly struggling either.

Younger sis has mental health problems and as a result has a lot of help and support from other members of the family in caring for her children, means my parents are closer to her children than mine IFSWIM as her children sleep at my parents 3 nights a week.

My youngest child suffers from Autism, ADHD and Global Development Delay, as a result he does not talk and is not potty trained. Not massively relavant but my dad is old fashioned and 'dosn't believe' in the conditions and thinks he is hard work and deliberately rude to not speak to people. As a result he is not close to my children AT ALL.

All 3 of us drive, my brother has just passed his test and does not have a car yet. I passed many years ago but do not have a car as can't afford to run one. Sis has a cheap little run around.

All 3 of us live very local to each other and we are a close family.

Phew that's it I think, don't want to drip feed!

Anyway my dad has just bought a new car (great for him) and told me my sis was buying the old one from him, again fine with me. The old one is 3 years old, excellent condition and worth around 6-7 thousand.

Anyway was chatting to sis who then told me that actually my dad was GIVING her the car, wasn't too happy about this as felt it was unfair considering she was the only one to already have a car and felt it would be better for dad to have sold it considering he could do with the money.

Anyway mentioned it to my dad who told me 'she needs it for the kids' not sure why as she has the little car and lets face it not many people NEED a car unless of course you work out of town etc. which none of us do.

Left it at that as I thought about it and I wouldn't have wanted to car anyway as I can't afford to run it so pointless to argue about. Although my dad knows that I am in the process of saving up for a cheap run around as with my DS having SEN it is hard to get around sometimes.

Anyway a week later sis SELLS THE CAR that has been given to her and keeps her little run around, the reason being she could not afford to insure it.

I am not fuming and think why on earth has she been given this car, to sell on and now have a few grand in her pocket. It seems my dad knew this was the plan and gave it to her anyway.

AIBU to think my dad is a complete twat and is clearly favouring one child over his other's. I am apparantly being a spoilt brat and should count myself lucky.

To make matters worse sis is has been saying all week how pleased she is because now she can afford a holiday after christmas and is going to buy a puppy with the rest. So it isn't like she had essential debts/ rent etc to clear.

OP posts:
Report
BluddyMoFo · 06/11/2011 01:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PessimisticMissPiggy · 06/11/2011 01:21

Oooo, tough one. YANBU unreasonable to be annoyed but it is your Dad's choice to do what he wants with his possessions. Would you feel differently if your bro had been given the car?

I bet your Dad is a bit annoyed at yours sis for telling you on purpose to make you angry? letting it slip.

Report
KatieMiddIeton · 06/11/2011 01:22

The opinions he holds about your son make him a twat. The other stuff pales in comparison.

Report
PessimisticMissPiggy · 06/11/2011 01:23

Sorry for the additional 'unreasonable' - I'm not pissed, it's sleep depravation!

Report
SacreLao · 06/11/2011 01:31

mofo That sums it up completely really, I feel like i'm being petty but of course it hurts as we all could do with the money, in fact so can my dad to be fair.

I would feel the same if he gave the car to my brother yes, and would have refused it if he offered it to me.

I think dad should have sold it and kept the money or at least split it between all 3 of us. He is forever going on about things not being fair so seems very hypocritical now.

E.G I asked my dad to give me a lift to my son's appointment as it was out of town and DS dosn't do well on busses and he refused saying it wouldn't be fair to my brother and sister as he never gives them lifts anywhere.

OP posts:
Report
PessimisticMissPiggy · 06/11/2011 01:34

Good point Katie but not to make excuses for him but a lot of older people don't understand these conditions because they 'didn't exist in their day' and don't understand that SN children/adults were blamed on bad parenting or hidden away.

My Great Aunt had SN and the whole family was told that she fell off a swing as a toddler and hit her head and was never the same after that. My mum discovered from her medical records later in her life (after great grandparents died ) that it was actually as a result of birth trauma/lack of oxygen. They either didn't understand or felt some shame.

OP congrats on your PG, don't get stressed about this.

Report
SacreLao · 06/11/2011 01:35

MissPiggy She without a doubt told me on purpose, but i'd have known anyway when she suddenly had a few grand in her pocket so dosn't really matter.

I get on very well with my brother and sister so it's not sibling rivalry so to speak, just hurts that my dad quite clearly thinks more of my sister than me and my brother, who bend over bloody backwards to help my parents and never ask anything in return.

I have my sister's 3 children here with me tonight, my dad would be the first person to be annoyed if I ever refused to have them (not that I would as I adore them) but I know full well he wouldn't help me or my brother as much as he helps her, even if we needed it.

OP posts:
Report
PessimisticMissPiggy · 06/11/2011 01:39

Okay, on reading about the lifts situation, yep he's not a model parent. YANBU and it would have been much fairer to split the money. It's done now, how do you think you can move forward from this event?

Again, apologies for the crap grammar and repetition.

Report
ViviPru · 06/11/2011 01:45

YANBU.

I totally get you OP which is due in no small part to your having posted one of the most articulate and reasonable AIBUs I've ever read.

What a nice person you sound. I hope nice things come your way and this situation becomes a distant memory soon.

Report
SacreLao · 06/11/2011 01:52

Vivi Thank you very much Blush

MissPiggy I'm not going to let it bother me, life's too short and way too busy to care. I suppose I wanted reassurance that I wasn't being a spoilt brat to feel hurt by this but sod it, what's done is done.

I like to think I can be the bigger person and hold my head up, at least I can say I stand on my own two feet.

OP posts:
Report
PessimisticMissPiggy · 06/11/2011 02:01

It sounds like you've got a really healthy attitude. Like you say, hold your head up, and concentrate your soon-to-be extended family Smile.

Report
banana87 · 06/11/2011 02:19

YANBU. Your dad IS a twat and your sister is selfish.

Report
hauntedstateofmind · 06/11/2011 02:36

I asked my dad to give me a lift to my son's appointment as it was out of town and DS dosn't do well on buses and he refused saying it wouldn't be fair to my brother and sister as he never gives them lifts anywhere

Wow your father sounds like a charmer. Not.

About the car YANBU. Your father has basically given your DSis a huge amount of money and she has kept it all. Neither have acted well.

Your father's attitude to you (and your son) is awful. I would be very upset personally and would be keeping well away from him.

Report
ChippingInAutumnLover · 06/11/2011 02:55

I asked my dad to give me a lift to my son's appointment as it was out of town and DS dosn't do well on buses and he refused saying it wouldn't be fair to my brother and sister as he never gives them lifts anywhere

That alone makes your Dad a complete twat in my book!! It amazes me the crap parents you read about on here :(

YANBU to be hurt by your Dad giving your DSis a few grand. It's not fair. I don't think it's necessary for parents to do the same thing for all of their children at the same time, but I think it's essential to be 'fair'. In this case he should have sold the car and kept the money or given you each some. There was no reason to give the money solely to your DSis.

WRT your Dad not accepting your sons SN dx - a lot of people of his generation think that they're just 'naughty kids' so I'm not surprised to read it (upset for your and your kids though) but what struck me is that he feels this way about your kids, but presumably accepts that your Dsis has mental health problems - what's that all about then??

... and yes, it was a well written OP, but by para 36 I was wondering when we were going to get down to the cat & his take on this Grin

Report
SacreLao · 06/11/2011 03:10

Chipping I could write a novel sometimes Blush everytime I post on here though I get told off for drip feeding so now start all AIBU posts by giving everyone a life story Grin

The not accepting my son's SEN is just his age, it didn't exist in his day and age so that's that.

My sister's mental health issues are slightly more complicated, she dosn't have 'diagnosed' mental health issues but as a result of an ex-partner physically / emotionally abusing her she has a lot of issues, proberly PTSD / Depression or something similar if she were to see a doctor.

My dad accepts this as it has a 'cause' so to speak and to be perfectly honest without the help she gets from the family her children would be on the social services radar hence why both parents are so involved and give her the help she needs.

OP posts:
Report
ChippingInAutumnLover · 06/11/2011 03:25

Maybe you should write a novel!! It's my own fault I know for telling you the other day that it would have been better if you'd put it in your op - I'd forgotten that Blush LOL



Maybe you should tell your Dad you dropped your DS on his head when he was a newborn...

My parents aren't much better. My Mum has a friend who has a teenage boy with SN, they stayed with her the other week and some of the stuff my Mum was saying afterwards ... as much as you try, you know you might as well just hit your head against the wall and be done with it :( Fortunately it was over the phone or I may have had to thwack her over the head with something heavy!!

Report
SacreLao · 06/11/2011 03:28

Lol, so had I actually Grin I just remember getting told off but not by who.

So it is OFFICIALLY Chipping's fault for the long OP!!!

Parent's eh, they drive you mad.

Makes you wonder if my kids will be posting things moaning about me in 20 years time or so.

OP posts:
Report
CailinDana · 06/11/2011 08:15

You sound like a very kind and reasonable person and it's a shame your father can't see that. I can totally understand why you're hurt. No matter how old we get we always want our parents' love and approval and when they do something petty and nasty like this it's horrible.

Report
LRDtheFeministDragon · 06/11/2011 11:02

Have you come across the Stately Homes threads in Relationships? They are really good for talking about issues with parents who are, basically, not very good parents. Sorry, but your dad obviously fits in that category.

You sound lovely and it must be incredibly hard to see your dad acting this way.

Report
diddl · 06/11/2011 11:16

Your Dad sounds awful-but then your sister could have shared the money also tbh.

Report
Poppyella · 06/11/2011 11:49

YANBU He sounds like a twat to me.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.