Mumsnet Talk

Has anyone else re read twilight after reading 50 shades and found they're opinion of Edward has changed? I used to love the first bit of twilight as a lovely romance as they fall for each other. I'm on the part where he goes to rescue bella from getting beat up when she goes dress shopping. And all i can see now is how dominating and strict Edward is! And he is! I can see where EL James got her ideas now. I never saw this side of Edward before. Now i can't get it outta my head. I feel twilight will forever be spoiled for me now still good but very different. Anyone else feel the same?

50 Shades Of Grey was originally Twilight Fanfiction.

She changed the names and released it as a book.

No because that is exactly how I saw Edward the first time I read Twilight.

The dreadful writing, poor plotting and unlikeable characters spoiled Twilight forever.

Thats what i'm saying. Since i read 50 shades and found out it was twilight fanfic, when i now re read twilight, all i can see is a really dominating male character! The sweet love story has now changed forever into a some what more adult thing all together!

I read amazing Wolfpack fanfiction instead now-can't read Bella/Edward at all! In most of the stories I like we agree that Bella was under thrall to vampire Edward and thus why she became vapid and weak willed!
Unfortunately that means I spend the films in a state of horror and denial!

Fanofthe it's interesting that you picked up on that part of edward which totally went over my head. Didn't see him as dominating alpha male at all! Do now though.

Have never been able to bring myself to read 50 Shades!

I like the Twilight books and haven't read 50 shades books but I think its always seemed obvious that Edward was emotionally manipulative bordering on abusive.

He disabled her car so she couldn't visit friends.

He regularly threatened to kill himself (by exposure to volturi) if she left.

He would withdraw/allow contact between the two when it suited him.

And don't get me started on Bella with her rediculously old fashioned outlook on life...

But I shall overlook all of this as out is fiction after all

God i noticed there is alot of stalking going on. Your right. It's like i'm reading a different book this time around. The rose tinted veil has been lifted! And don't forget he keeps glamouring her to soften her up and bend her to his will!

Oops x-post glad its not just me then

You've actually read Twilight twice?

i had never looked at it like that before.

I'm with LadyMargo here. reread Twilight?

That's on a par with storing open wine imo

Nope, I always saw it for the twishite that it is. If it helps more people realise it then dammit maybe 50 Shades does have a purpose after all.

<ponders the cleverness of the universe>

Well erm lol. To be honest, i really enjoyed em first read as a summer beach easy read. I like romance, excitment and vampires. Since the new films out soon, i figured i'd re read along side a hard going novel as some light relief. But all i can see now is a dominating aggressive male which has kinda spoilt it for me. Any other suggestions?

Got sent this link a while back
www.comicbookmovie.com/images/users/uploads/9186/twilight-ending-blade.jpg

and this one...

www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZwM3GvaTRM

And don't forget he keeps glamouring her to soften her up and bend her to his will!

Bella couldn't be glamoured due to her special power. <saddo alert>

Oh no gobbler. I am of the crowd who enjoyed 50 shades and the da vinci code but i don't expect intelligent writing, just an entertaining easy read. When your trying to decipher beowulf from old english, you need some light relief

Have just finished the 50 shades books and actually really enjoyed them, found them far more vanilla than I thought they would be but yes, you are sadly right.

I knew they were originally Twilight fan fiction though so I guess I spoiled it for myself by reading them.

Quite badly written though. I haven't been able to take them as serious as Twilight and I swear the next time I see a hyphen I may scream.

If you like easy-reading vampire stuff there is no shortage around! but have you read any of the Sookie Stackhouse ones?

Schro. I read that as hymen!!!!!!! lol yeah i thought 50 was a bit vanilla. It's nowt when you've read somat like american psycho (my mind will be forever warped) It was really funny how all my mates were sooo shocked at it!

I LOVE the sooky novels and true blood too. Brilliant. Never read anne rice, but i reckon it's better written and much darker stuff.

Yeah, I borrowed the first one from my fairly prudish SIL. MIL has read it too, I will never look at either of them the same again.

Arf @ "hymen".

I normally read BDSM library, so the sex scenes seemed really boring.

Found it hilarious when he tried to explain what a spreader bar is though, surely the clue is in the name?

I found Bella and Edward's relationship very disturbing before I read 50 Shades.

Although neither were as disturbing as the colleague who insisted that Christian Gray is her ideal man

Yes, I was a bit when a friend said she wanted to be Anastasia Grey. The threatening, controlling relationship side of the plot goes over the heads of many people (including EL James?).

I was the same as OP when I first started reading Twilight, but it got me thinking, and by the end of the series, I had sussed out Edward.

I wanted Ana (50 shades) to see sense and go back to Jose.
<reminds self is not real>

Ha ha schro. Yeah the name kinda gives it away. Will look at that link. I'm a sometimes fan of the marquis de sade so i'm pretty difficult to shock. But i'm surprised by how different i now feel about edward. Hmmm.

not read 50 shades as...it sounds shyte tbh but on my first reading of twilight i found edwards behaviour weird and not very romantic at all really, and bella's reaction puh-theh-tic!

no, but then i read 50 shades first... i've studiously ignored the existence of twilight until the last 2 weeks when i needed something to read and i was bought the books second hand.

i'm loving them, and the films and am so used to reading/writing fanfic for other genres as a hobby that i can enjoy the twilight books without my 50 shades of drab experience affecting my enjoyment.

So glad others see what a twonk Edward is. I only just joined the Twilight bandwagon and am appalled that none of my friends see what a controlling, abusive relationship it is! I KNOW it's nit real but still.

Love the Buffy version.

Honestly hellobear, it's like reading a different book this time round. He is such a bully. Just got to the bit when she first goes to his home and he scares her on purpose by flinging her across the room and restraining her. Then he laughs. The humiliates her be keeping her restrained infront of Alice! Deary me. And this is suposed to be a good read for teenage girls?

I know tigggy this is what teenage girls think love looks like.

NO!!!

When he told her he watched her sleeping I thought what a creep. But Bella just 'gasped' and accepted it. V odd.

But I guess that's what a relationship with a vampire looks like!

Hmmm, am I perhaps taking this too seriously???

You see, I have a nearly 12-yo who so far has shown no interest in reading the Twilight series, but I have told her that if she does, I will read them too and will want to talk to her about the nature of real male/female relationships.

At the moment she's reading LOTR, which with hindsight is very male dominated - but at least it has Eowyn.