ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
How to keep the grandparents in check...(59 Posts)
....in the nicest possible way?. My DD is 2. She is my parents first and only grandchild and my PIL's second of 2. We are so lucky, because they both adore DD and thoroughly spoil her. However, at Christmas, I wish they would just back off a bit. I think the problem is that when DH and I were little, neither family had much money. However, both sets of grandparents are better off than we are now and want to spend a fortune on DD. I am grateful, but it is overwhelming and ends up treading on the stuff that we do. An example would be the 'Advent Calender', last year we bought DD a lovely wooden calender that we could fill with our own treats. I managed (just) to convince my own mum not to buy DD a chocolate calender, but MIL bought one and gave it to DD even though I asked her not to. It is only a small thing, but it is annoying. DD doesn't need two, and we want the wooden one to be special. The same happened with the stocking, we bought her a lovely, personalized one, hoping to start a tradition, we told everyone about it, but she ended up with 5!! All of them personalized with her name. All of them filled with the same type of stockingy presents that we had already bought. This year, as with the two previous years, we are going to PILs on Christmas morning for breakfast and my parents in the afternoon for dinner and, if the two previous years are anything to go by, DD is going to have huge piles of presents at both houses that dwarf what 'Santa' has bought her. MIL also insists that 'Santa' has bought the gifts at her house too which I find annoying. I just want them all to follow our lead a bit more, and I want to be able to tell them they are getting carried away and treading on things that we are doing but without hurting their feelings. They do mean well, but we are the parents. I have already tried suggesting that DD goes to stay overnight with each set of grandparents and they can do special things together rather than just buy her loads of stuff. It seems to fall of deaf ears though. What do I do?
My parents allow me to leave presents at their house - they quite like having stuff for her to play with. My IL's dont though because they have two grand daughters and feel it wouldnt be fair if one played with the others toy. I dont know how to do an eyeroll emoticon but I do think that is silly! Im letting MIL do a stocking, she does one for each of us and I wouldnt even dream of asking her to stop doing her tradition. However, it stays at her house. Same for my mum. The advent calenders I am going to insist on though. DD does not need three. And the presents - Santa only delivers to our house, the rest are from grandparents/aunties etc. Last year DD was more excited to give them presents than open her own anyway! (Although, that was just because she wanted the sparkly wrapping paper once they had opened them!)
My inlaws are like this and it drives me nutty telling dd's the presents are from Santa, insisting on spending hundreds on them when we don't, buying toys they don't want or are too young for them. I sound like an unhinged ungrateful cow whenever I talk about it tho and many people can't see the problem. But I can sympathise with you 100% op.
Last year I got very annoyed at dh and he agreed (it helped we were moving house just after Christmas and suddenly didn't have enough moving boxes after his parents toy gifts!)
We made up a new rule and have been bed t firm with them. They can give 3 gifts from them, NOT Santa, he visits our house. They have 1 dinner table gift (tradition) and she can buy them a story book and pj's for bedtime (we stay at their house) it sounds very controlling and I guess it is, but I know they have already got them pjs, slippers, dressing gowns and 2 books each for bed time. Their table gift comes in 2 parts so has been wrapped separately and one of their 3 gifts is a bag with lots of little things wrapped inside. Christmas is still 2 months away.
It's mainly upsetting because she steps on my family traditions and has already bought things I was planning on getting for the girls. But I do know they love them very much an his is how they show their love so I do know I have to accept it to a degree.
We also cannot discuss presents in advance because my mother then buys whatever I have said we were going to get. Then she "pretends" she's forgotten
Her: what are you thinking of getting Ds?
Me: well dh and I haven't really discussed it yet but probably Lego. He's really into making things and wants a Lego police car. So probably a Lego police car.
Her: we were thinking we would buy <insert ridiculously expensive item which is not really age appropriate>
Me: erm, that sounds nice although you really don't need to spend so much and he might be a little young..?
Christmas Day: DM arrives with a fleet of Lego police cars, vans and motorbikes and some play mobile and <insert ridiculous gift> plus a million outfits.
I am going to be blunt but DH and I don't have any parents so DS aged 5 has no grandparents. Yes, I can see how elements of it are annoying but you are lucky they are there to give extra gifts.
DS gets what we give him and that is it bar a t shirt from a relative who lives overseas.
I think I would get everyone together and round the table. Tell them you love how they are keen and excited but that last year there were too many duplicates and can you all agree what the best plan is. Give everyone a list at the end so they know exactly what is what.
Sorry if I sound blunt but there wasn't a pleasant way of saying my first paragraph. Hope you manage to get everything agreed.
No need to apologise Crutchlow. You are right, we are very lucky. Going to talk to them honestly but kindly. Like I said before; we are grateful, its just a bit much x
With the very greatest of respect Crutchlow just because some people have it worse doesn't mean the situations people are in are not valid and worthy of a complaint or a moan or even despair. It is a bit unfair to suggest that if we just all got together and spoke about it all would be resolved, as if we haven't already tried this. Some things are just not that easily resolved - if they were we wouldn't all be here.
We would all love to have a happy Christmas with our relatives alive and well, where everyone is thoughtful and considerate and pulls together. For some this is impossible because their relatives have passed on but for others, like the people on this thread, the problem is the thoughtless or difficult behaviour of others and the fact that you can't say anything for fear of being accused of being ungrateful or failing to appreciate how lucky we are that the grandparents are still alive.
I do sympathise with you, I really do and it must be very hard but you are comparing apples and oranges. The absence of loving grandparents cannot be compared with the presence or thoughtless/controlling grandparents. There is no top trumps to be played here; a miserable Christmas remains a miserable Christmas.
I think that is what I find difficult about mil K8, she is so controlling. She just does what she wants anyway regardless of what I say. Im going to have to just be tougher with them. X
Where did I say the OPs comments were not valid K8? I have quite clearly said I can see how annoying it can be. That I think they should get round a table and discuss it all and that I hope she resolves it agreeably.
Wails! Name change fail!
Anyways, hopefully you will get everything resolved and everyone is happy.
Crutchlow - while I can see how this might seem ab unimportant problem compared to yours, that doesn't stop it being a problem - rather like saying yes, your broken leg is worse than my stubbed toe, but knowing you have a broken leg does not make my stubbed toe stop hurting.
OP - I'll join with you in having "the chat" - going to be firm with my parents this week
which they will ignore and make me seeth at Christmas, because their attempts to be number one grandparents is apparently more important than me and DH being happy at Christmas
You imply that it is easily resolved, which suggests the issue is not a valid one. Did you miss the bits where OP says she's already discussed it? Or all the other posts on this thread? Annoying is an understatement in some cases. When you spend the whole of Christmas Eve on tenterhooks because you know that grandma is going to whip out new Christmas PJs (even though she knows you have already bought some) and the pile of Christmas presents is bigger than the Christmas tree (despite multiple conversations and agreement that presents will be limited) and you spend the whole of Christmas Day and Boxing Day managing the tantrums of over excited children who have just had a present orgy and have barely looked at anything and don't want to interact with other people but just have more stuff... it does really make it hard to have a happy, family time.
Your suggestion that it is easily resolved by a round-table discussion is to minimise the situation which implies the op (and the rest of us!) have not tried hard enough to resolve the situation. In some cases it cannot be resolved, only tolerated.
x-posted with DontmindifIdo who has said it better than me.
In keeping up with this on my touch screen phone and i think i just accident reported a post! I tried to press the back button so hopefully it stopped it. So sorry, I think it was yours K8. In not sure how to un-report it! Please ignore me mumsnet HQ
Right. Going to the inlaws for Sunday dinner and will attempt the chat again. Wish me luck!
I find the whole thing really, really stressful. We have to be careful with our cash because I've been on maternity leave and for other reasons but we're not badly off. I feel like we're seen as being poor or tight and actually I think we have a healthy attitude vs the obscene profligacy.
Wow, are you me? This is only DD's second Christmas (first grandchild both sides), but the excess has always stressed me out, and it seems to get worse each year. I just want to spend time celebrating with family without this pressure to reciprocate when people have bought a ridiculous amount of stuff that we neither need nor want. It really does upset me actually, but I have no idea what to do about it, I'm afraid. Requests to keep things low key seem to fall on deaf ears.
ooh partial success! I just took the bull by the horns and had a word.
My dad called, it's his birthday next week and I'd sent him a message asking if he had anything he wanted. Apparently he's got a list of books he wants, but mentioned I should only get him one or two (as much as he loves buying shed loads of stuff for other people, he doesn't like to recieve much stuff!). I said I'd get a few of them and put the others to one side for Christmas. He then said "I suppose [DS] is old enough this year to have a list for Father Christmas, you'll have to let us know what's on it so we can get him something." I then said that it might be better this year if he only gets one or two gifts from each person - and if they wanted to spend the same, I could give suggestions of slightly more expensive items, or put money in DS's savings. I pointed out that as it's also DS's birthday at Christmas, he often gets all his gifts on Christmas day, I reelled off the list of people who'll buy a gift for DS, and pointed out that even if close family (just both sets of grandparents, DH's and my siblings, DS's godmother and my godmother) only bought DS one gift each for Christmas and one for Birthday, that's still 20 parcels to open before he even gets anything from DH and I or his stocking from 'Father Christmas'.
Dad actually said that he'd noticed last year that DS seemed to get bored of opening pressies last christmas by tea time when he was handed a loads of birthday pressies from my brother. (!!!) I said that yes, DS seems to get overwhelmed by it all and I'd rather they just get him one or two gifts, if they want to get him more things, they could put somethings to one side and give him a gift in January (ok, still not reducing the amount of crap in my house, but at least staggering it a bit to help DS actually have time to play with his toys, rather than every time he starts to play with something, being handed another parcel to open).
We've left it that he'll talk to Mum about reducing the sheer quantity of things, and they won't get anythign until I send a list of ideas, also that DVDs and books might be good "little extra" gifts - but that giving them to me to give him between Christmas and New Year on rainy days when pre-school is closed rather than on Christmas day might be a better idea.
Oh and as DD will only be 6 months old and she already has lots of DS's old toys, they've agreed to get her clothes for Christmas.
Now, does anyone think this will actually happen???!?!?!
Xmas day is also DSs birthday so he gets a massive pile of gifts. His first Xmas/birthday my mum and MIL were being all secretive about what they had bought him.
My mum lives 5 minutes away and MIL lives 100 odd miles away. PIL couldn't come visit on Xmas day and were coming on the 27th instead. My mum came over on Xmas day.
Anyway, it turned out that they had both bought him the same... but because my mums had already been opened, assembled and played with, the one from MIL had to be the one to be exchanged (she wouldn't entertain the idea of leaving it at hers for DS to play with there).
She was not a happy MIL, not at all. Now I insist that both sets of grandparents actually communicate with each other.
shes only two so you can nip this in the bud now.as far as them buying stuff im not sure what you can do,i have 5 and my mil has 20 grandchildren in total so thats not an issue for us,my mum spends a lot on them and buys them stuff i probably wouldnt choose but as they are getting older she asks me directly what i think they would like.
Its the other stuff that bothers me,the answer is easy,TELL THEM!thats what i did,mil told my lot that santa had bought their presents and i just said "oh no they know that you buy the presents" (we dont really do santa or anything the kids know its just a story so your response would be different,like santa only buys the presents at our house")
I spoke to mil and she agreed to 2 or 3presents plus clothes and stocking. She also agreed not to get an advent calendar either. She has bought xmas eve pjs, but I have asked her to keep them for Christmas day night and she was fine. I told her that i found it overwhelming last year and she said 'thats as it should be' but I stood my ground. It was okay in the end, im just hoping she sticks to it. Will have the chat with my own mum too. I find it easier to talk to my own mum so it shouldn't be a problem. Thanks all x
Why not ask them to put money in a savings account and get little presents if they insist?
I am a GM with one GS and it is his first Christmas and I will be talking to DD before buying a single thing.
Agree with those saying that its particularly mean of them to trample stockings - on one of the fun privileges that parents get to counteract all the drudgery. I would be hopping about this. The least they can do is stick to the traditions that you and DH have decided on.
We have this but have worked out that we can direct them into larger presents and they then limit the rest because they only have so much cash. I exchange clothes I don't like. Mil tends to go mad on the sale rails and most things are the wrong size/ season or I think too grown up.
Suggestions for presents are outside climbing frames/ playhouses, trips to Lego land, help decorate child's bedroom. Help with storage units for toys! The vito now is if you buy a massive/loads of stuff it has to come with a storage solution or it goes back to their house. That of course is another solution to it. Get mil to keep some of the toys at theirs for when you go there.
This may sound crass but the more expensive the better as it leaves less to be spent of tuns of toys that just get dusty.
The principle of the advent calendar would piss me off as mil went against what you said. This IMO is not acceptable!
To give you some hope the older your child gets the more expensive the toys get and the smaller they are
There is always regifting for children's parties and some shops will let you take stuff back. You can't stop them but you can direct them.
It's taken me 6 years to get it to this point.
life's too short to get upset about an advent calendar.
at two kids really don't care about tradition, and by the time they're four they'll be wanting all the marketed ones in the shops and wooden ones will seem boring to them. Those types of traditions are more about the parents than the children.
As for the excessive buying of Christmas presents, I would be more inclined to berate the commercialisation that is Christmas and point out to the parents that it shouldn't be about competitive giving.
I just let them get on with it. Last year DCs had 5 Advent Calendars between them, they had one each, DH and I scoffed the rest. As for the presenst just put some away once opened and swap toys around now and again. It's not worth upsetting the GPs over it, it really isn't.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.