Mumsnet members get a 10% discount from Boden (including free returns and free delivery), The White Company, sweaty Betty, Luxury Family Hotels, JoJo Maman Bebe, Siblu, Blooming Marvellous, GLTC, Bump to 3 (the official online shop for Grobags) and more. Click here for more info Join mumsnet here.
Mumsnet Discussions:
Relationships
: I have posted about this before - dp has bashed up the kitchen in a rage this morning. Terrified the dc and the dog and the cat. He is now in bed asleep.
(92 messages)
Oh you poor thing! How are the children now? How are you? Is there anyone you can go and talk to? Are you or your children hurt? Sorry I'm asking you so many questions and haven't given you any advice
the best advice I can give you is to show your children that you are trying to make their situation better or they may not forgive you for making them suffer through this. Sorry if that sounds harsh.
I am ok - just tidying up and trying to work. The children are ok they are at school and nursery (5 & 3). They seem fine - and I tried to get on with things as normal.
I know - just not sure really what to do Dp suffers from depression - which he will not admit to. He can be fine for weeks and is the best dad. Then the depression takes over and he flies into rages. He hasn't done too much damage just a couple of broken plates and a cup - but it is what it signifies. Just don't know what to do
Jazzicat-I lived in this sort of environment as a child and it is very scary-it is the unpredictability that causes such huge amounts of stress. I know that you must be feeling utterly helpless but you have to act for the sake of your children. Unless this behaviour stops you need to remove your children from it. As they get older and more aware of what is going on the harder it will become for them to deal with. I really feel for you and I hope that you can resolve this quickly for all of you
I'm not sure you'll want to hear this but my close friend who is now in her late 40's has never forgiven her mother for not leaving her violent father.
Worse than the physical abuse was the mental - she described sittig at the top of the stairs scared to come downstirs in case her fatehr was in "a mood". She is terribly insecure and needy with men and as a result has a history of fractured relationships and now a single mother herself.
When he gets up how is he likely to explain his behaviour? Could you threaten him with an ultimatum - not nice I know! Either he seeks help or he leaves?
you are the only person who can protect your children and they have the right to expect it from you.
Depression may explain it but it still doesnt mean that your childrne should be expected to live with it. Perhaps you could move out (move him out) temporarily with the condition that if he gets his depression treated you will reconsider.
Jazzi, my dh gets depression too. The first time it happened I eventually told him to get treatment or get out. I meant it. It's tough love, you have to MAKE him get treatment.
He went on ADs, and life got easier. Since then he has had two more bouts, but now trusts me to see him on the downward spiral, and will go to Drs (after a couple of rows) when I tell him he needs to.
I have just tried to speak to him and it culminated in an argument - he will not accept responsibility and is trying to blame me for his mood. Can't kick him out - it is his house.
my dad was like this when we were little. i can always remember having a sick feeling in my stomach when he was due home in case he was in a mood. i lived, day in, day out under the most enormous stress. i was a child.
when i got older i was angry so i got drunk, slept around, got pierced/pregnant/arrested
is that what you want for your children ?
please get out. it doesn't have to be over, just get you and your children safe for now and then get him the help he obviously needs and maybe in time things can be good. but for now, the situation is unhealthy and as their mother, you need to protect your children and their well being
Yes my mum was depressed - well, looking back on it she was probably quite mentally ill. Unpredictable violent destructive outbursts then periods of calm when everyone was so pathetically grateful we'd all be lovely to everyone. Then she would lose it again and throw all my stuff out of the window/smash up the kitchen/break every plate in the house etc etc. My dad could have made lives easier for his children but he chose not to. I therefore have understanding, but little tolerance, of people with children who choose to live their lives in this way.
Ok, do you have somewhere you and the children could go? Family, close friends?
You are NOT responsible for HIS mood, HE is responsible for how HE feels and if it is out of his control he needs to accept he needs help not find someone to blame.
You do not need this, you need all the strength you have to care and protect your children. You can do this!!
I am so sorry (but unfortunately not altogether surprised) that he is still being awful towards you and the children. Such men rarely if ever change and it is not down to you to "fix" or "rescue" him.
Your children do not need such a man around in their lives. Why should they have to see all this crap at such a young age, bad enough at any age. They are taking all this in you know - do not kid yourself that they are not (not suggesting you are btw). You can clear up and make things "normal" again but you cannot yourself solve the underlying problems.
On a wider level what are you both teaching these children about relationships?. Would you actually want them to grow up thinking that smashing up the kitchen in a rage is somehow normal?. Of course not!!. A child's house should be a sanctuary, not a warzone.
You are only responsible for your own self and your children. Not him.
I would agree entirely with the other responses; I think you know what you have to do. Womens Aid would also be able to help you.
"I have just tried to speak to him and it culminated in an argument - he will not accept responsibility and is trying to blame me for his mood. Can't kick him out - it is his house. "
Of COURSE it becomes an argument. If he's depressed he isn't rational, he can't reasonably explain his behaviour, nor discuss it, and everyone and everything else is to blame. Don't argue, don't try to reason with him. If you can't kick him out then go yourself, and take the children. Just go,shake him up, and make it clear that he either goes to get treatment, or you don't come back.
In a few weeks time the 5 year old will be off from school - I expect school and nursery feel like a safe place for them right now. If you can't do something today can't you plan to stay with someone and give you and your children some space and somewhere safe to stay, when the school breaks up? It could really lead to much more when they are off.
But agree very much with the advice and what Kew put.
As a child in this situation you have no choice or control in the matter -- you turn into a super-coper in the vain hope that if you're good enough, things will come right in your family. Needless to say it doesn't work, and you assume it's because you're not good enough, which follows you throughout your life.
A very destructive pattern to impose on a small child with a vulnerable developing mind. Yes, you are a victim too, but YOU HAVE A CHOICE and your kids don't.
Deal with it or get out. It is NOT okay, whatever excuses he may make for his behaviour.
I cannot afford to go anywhere - we have no money and he is saying that he will not move out. If I don't like it then I must go. How am I supposed to do that with literally nothing?
I think you need to go to some kind of rescue centre. You need to be strong for your children here you just need to do it - get away. YOU are the adult and they are vulnerable children, do you think these frights are doing them any good?
"I cannot afford to go anywhere - we have no money and he is saying that he will not move out. If I don't like it then I must go. How am I supposed to do that with literally nothing?"
Other poster's have already said, you can go to women's aid, or ask the council for re-homing. Do you have any family? Won't your children's grandparents/aunts/uncles/godparents someone offer them somewhere to stay temporarily so you can get your dp sorted out?
im really sorry you're going through this, but it realyl ISNT a case of being able to afford to leave, you MUST leave, like people have suggested womens aid and other areas WILL help, you CAN NOT stay here with your children
The irony is I work within the field of domestic violence. I know all of the procedures and what I can do etc. I just don't think this warrants such an extreme reaction. and I certainly do not want to take away resources from those that really need the help. I I know I am being really crap I just feel overwhelmed with it all. Sometimes I just fucking hate him for doing this to me and my gorgeous boys.
as well as yourself you must think about you absolutely MUST put your children first!, theyre old enough to understand and you also sound wise enough to know what you must do, you already know a lot about this kind of thing, so you will have contacts..you dont think its 'that' extreme..imagine what it feels like to your two tiny children
Right then you have made your decision. If you think this is something you can live around like the proverbial elephant in the living room. Just don't expect your children to thrive emotionally and physically from the decision you have made.
Of course you have choices. The less you have now, the less you have to lose. Phone Women's Aid, phone a solicitor, call the police on him, go to a refuge, whatever it takes.
As kids we would have far preferred to live in a bedsit with a mother who chose to protect us than in a 4-bed detached house with a mother who stood by while we were all tyrannised and terrified by our father's violent moods.
By doing nothing you are effectively making a choice to put your dp before your children. One day they will understand the implications of your choice, and they won't forgive you.
If I had a neighbour from whom I kept hearing disturbances like this, I would report them to SS.
I really would.
It is never good for children to be living in such circumstances.
I've been depressed myself, still am. But if my behaviour were causing me to lose control like that I'd get it treated OR leave myself rather than subject my kids to that.
Jazzicat, I know, you think that "This doesn't happen to people like me" Well it does, it is happening.
And your gorgeous boys don't deserve this.
Now you haven't answered any questions we've asked. You come on asking "what should I do", but don't want to follow the course of action we suggest.
Then why did you post? What do YOU think you should do?
If it was me, I'd be asking my family for help. Not saying "I'm a victim of domestic violence", but saying "dp has a health problem, I need to move the children away from him to encourage him to sort this out. Can you help us please?"
I believe, albeit contravercially, that if you stay with men like this it makes you indeed a very bad Mother. I also speak from bitter bitter experience.
"The irony is I work within the field of domestic violence. I know all of the procedures and what I can do etc.
Even more reason to take a stand then against him.
"I just don't think this warrants such an extreme reaction. and I certainly do not want to take away resources from those that really need the help".
Okay so what to your mind does warrant an extreme reaction?. Hitting you and the kids?. You being in such a toxic environment have become conditioned to his rubbish, you are not yourself to blame for thinking like this. You will NOT be taking any resources away from other women.
I think as well it is only when you and the children are fully away from him will you realise how awful he actually is. He cares for no-one but himself.
"I know I am being really crap I just feel overwhelmed with it all. Sometimes I just fucking hate him for doing this to me and my gorgeous boys".
He has made you feel overwhelmed; women in domestic violence situations often feel overwhelmed. You see that these situations played out again and again in your working life. Don't just react and tidy up around him - ACT!!!. Don't let him do this to you all anymore. Take some power back woman!!!.
Don't let your boys potentially become physical and or mental abusers because of what they have seen as children. If you were ultimately to stay with him they will not thank you as adults for doing so. They will likely blame you instead for putting him before them. Other posters have posted along the same lines and they themselves saw this when they were children. Take heed of their words.
Also, by putting up with this unreasonable behaviour, you are NOT helping your dp.
He is obviously not happy with his life, he can't cope with it. He needs treatment. You must force him into some sort of treatment. Losing his family may be the spur he needs (it was for my dh).
My exDH was like this - mainly verbally and emotionally abusive, and the occasional shove or throwing things in my direction. I didn't class it as domestic violence as he wasn't really hitting me. I also made lots of excuses - young children are hard work - they were 3 and 1 at the time etc etc.
The turning point for me came when he did start hitting, kicking and punching me - not often initially, but the frequency gradually increased. When my 3 yr old DD pushed his drink over trying to get him to stop shouting at me and he shouted at her instead, I knew things weren't going to get any better.
I was fortunate in having a well paid job, and I made him leave, and I have never regretted it. He was a right pain for a long time - blaming me for taking his children away from him etc.
This was 10 years ago now, and I am now remarried to a wonderful man with a 20mth old, my 2 DDs are lovely well-adjusted and happy girls. They still see their father and have a good relationship with him - he has never been violent towards them. With hindsight I can see the relationship hadn't been healthy for a long time before we split - but I ignored the warning signs, even though I had tried to get him along to Relate.
Ironically he was very keen to go to Relate once we'd split up - but it was too late.
My advice would be that you do need to leave - he has no incentive to change if you stay and put up with it. I found it a great relief to be on my own and hadn't realised quite how stressed I had been tiptoeing around him.
My mother is 54, married at 17. My father still bashes up the house and even bit her until she bled the other night. I have no feelings for him but resent her for staying with him whilst he roared in temper, smashed up our house including my stereo that I had saved up for for 11 months when I was 11. I am really sorry about your situation but feel you must get out, now.
He has gone to work now - I am grateful to you all for sharing your advice and experiences with me. I know things have to change and it is down to me to do that. I have a job interview for a job away from here that I will take the boys. I cannot live like this anymore. The most important thing in my life are my boys and their well-being. I have to acknowledge that he will not change and is unwilling to accept reponsibility or that he needs help. Thanks again everyone.
To be honest I don't care about my dp anymore - I haven't for a long time. I just don't want to deprive my boys of their dad. As I said he is normally a fantastic father. Thnigs between him and I have not been good for a long time, but as a father he is great. But I don't want my ds's to believe that this is acceptable especially as he has not apologised.
'as a father he is great. But I don't want my ds's to believe that this is acceptable especially as he has not apologised. '
a great father doesn't behave like this and blame it on his wife.
a great father gets help when he's ill and can't cope because he doesn't want it to impact on his kids lives in a negative way, or as little as possible.
his behaviour is not acceptable. you can't say 'sorry' and then continue to behave like this.
did you ask your boys when they were scared of him how great a father they thought he was. He will still be their father - he just needs to sort his shit out because if he doesn;t they will end up spending as much time apart from him as they possibly can as they get the opportunity when they get a bit older.
Yes I know - the children wanted me to take them to school this morning. Normally dp takes the elder boy. Ds1 wanted me to take him which is a first as he loves being with dp. I just think that we all lose our tempers sometimes, and it is important that children understand the consquences of this and that saying sorry and explaining can help children to understand how to deal with conflict. Dp hasn't and won't and I feel this is unacceptable. It is bad enough he has lost his rag - but an apology and explantion to me especially would go a long way. All dp could say was that it is my fault!
Jazzicatz, there are lots of people who work professionally with people affected by domestic violence who think 'it can't happen to me'. And are too embarrassed to seek help themselves - including some who have posted on this site.
It can happen to anyone - don't let pride stop you seeking help, sweetie.
I do hope you get out to a place of safety - for you and your children.
Jazzicatz - You should get out if you feel you or the children are in danger.
BUT, my dad was like this and never hit us and I would not have wanted him off the scene because of it.
He was lovely and cuddly and played with us. But he would lose his temper in a flash, shout and throw plates about. It was scary, and it has affected me. I really wish he had realised how bad it was and had got help. My parents ended up divorcing.
Now I have two young children of my own (5 and 2) and I can see how easy it is to become detached from your partner, and how easy it is to become depressed. My dh, who is a SAHD, often feels gloomy and can be very grumpy sometimes. He will always apologise for inflicting his mood on other people - not that that makes it OK!
Anyway, I'm just saying that your dh needs to realise that it is unacceptable, serious, and he is in danger of losing you and the kids if he doesn't get help. It's OK to have an exit strategy but could you not also consider that he could get help and become a happier person for himself and his family. Things might even improve between the two of you if you discuss it without blame and honestly. I know that I can get into a situation with my dh when he is stressed out where I think I could do without him. But when we talk over what's happening and why I find the friend I fell in love with in the first place is still there. Bringing up small children can just be v. stressful.
Although what my dad did was wrong, I love him dearly, and I think if my parents had been a bit older they might have sat down and talked about it instead of my mum unilaterally making the decison that the family was splitting up.
Fondant - thank you for your post. you have summed up what I was trying to say totally - but am too rubbish at. I cannot say I love him anymore as this has been going on for so long. But he is the father of my children and for that he will always be very special. I don't want to split my family up - but think it may be my only option.
He threw stuff about, which led to those items being broken. It could have been far worse, but it was enough to frightn the boys and the dog and the cat.
Mmm - that is pretty scary. It would probably be enough for me to call a time out! eg ask for time apart so you can both think about things.
Is there somewhere he could go for a few days (relatives)? Maybe then you could start talking about how you are feeling and how you see your future together.
I would def consider what the exit options are, but leave the door open to the possibility that he could confront his demons, get help, and change. It would make his life better, and help the kids, even if you end up splitting up!
As I'm sure you know, violence can escalate. My mum's friend went through something similar (albeit alcohol-fuelled); it started off with breaking objects and one day ended in rape. When they finally divorced they were in family therapy for some time (the older child who was about 9 or 10 at the time was particularly affected).
Good luck, I'm sure you will find the strength to act positively for all of your sakes.
If you leave him now, then once you're apart he may be able to establish a good relationship with the DCs. If you stay with him, then things will inevitably escalate and the chances are your DCs will end up hating him.
It's so hard, isn't it. My mum is still with my dad, despite him being a violent brute. She denies how truly awful he is, and forgives him for his threats and bruises. I have suffered from eating problems and severe depression because of my parents behaviour. One brother beats up his wife, and the other is being treated for depression. All of us have suffered from problems with jobs/money, and in terms of relationships. The Domestic Violence helpline is fantastic. They also understand that some people will not leave or cannot easily leave. They also said that there is little point in trying to diagnose someone who is violent. Unless they seek help for their behaviour, it will continue unabated and unchallenged.
Whatever else, please keep both yourself and your children safe!
Jazzi you've got to get out. I can see it would be easy to settle in again because his temper will ease BUT you know it's going to come back. You can't let anyone frighten your boys in this way. They don't deserve it and you need to make sure they don't suffer lasting effects.
Also you may well be doing your DP a favour because it may force him to get some kind of serious help for himself. I mean, why would he bother to get help if you and the boys stick around for him anyway?
Thanks all again for your kind messages. Found that dp had also bashed a hole in the downstairs loo which I have only noticed today. I am trying to get sorted out for my interview next week which will provide me with an exit strategy - if I don't get it then I have arranged to stay with my parents. He is still at his mothers and so far we haven't spoken.
Jazzi, if you work in the field presumably you are aware that you can apply for a non molestation injunction and an occupation order in order that you and the children are protected and that he can be forced to leave the house, irrespective of the fact that it's in his name.
If unsure, get yourself a free half hour with a family solicitor. All good family lawyers belong to www.resolution.org.uk