Mumsnetter ratings
(9 reviews)
| Overall |
 |
Mumsnetter reviews
Report this review
From:
LoveBuckets
on 10-May-09 13:21
Overall rating 1.0
Syrupy emotional blackmail, it's exactly how a British comedian would write if he was doing a parody of the American sentimentalist stereotype. There are so many ways to write an uplifting, optimistic tale without resorting to sacharine. You can have your heartstrings pulled far more pleasantly in a lot of scifi or fantasy, and there's usually a lot more imagination, humour and a cracking adventure too - why settle for such a lazy writer?
more reviews...
0 people said they found this review useful.
The small ads
Report this review
From:
kslatts
on 09-May-09 18:13
Overall rating 7.0
I quite enjoyed this book.
0 people said they found this review useful.
Report this review
From:
Mogsmum
on 01-Sep-08 13:06
Overall rating 6.0
I loved this book! Yes, it was a little cliched, but I found it heart warming and poignant
1 person said they found this review useful.
Report this review
From:
JayneF
on 21-Aug-08 21:27
Overall rating n/a
I thought it was great! But I thought his other book "Tuesdays with Morrie" was just dreadful.
0 people said they found this review useful.
Report this review
From:
HumphreyPillow
on 02-Aug-08 16:22
Overall rating 8.0
I enjoyed this book. Not as good as 'Tuesdays With Morrie' by the same author, but still worth a read.
Some interesting ideas, and well rounded characters.
Certainly doesn't deserve a place in the Worst book section.
1 person said they found this review useful.
Showing reviews 1 to 5 of 9.
1 |
2 |
next page