Mumsnet Talk

"The country's most popular meeting point for parents" The Times
  Topics | Active | Search  

Mumsnet latest

Tip of the day

Only the very brave wear clothes with no pockets when they take their children out. tigermoth

Quote of the week

David Cameron on whether The Thick of It accurately represents the Conservative publicity machine: "I love The Thick of It. V funny... but only true about the other lot (not)."

 

Recipe of the week

penguinmum's creamy fish pie: smoky, seasonal fish in a creamy white sauce with grated, rather than mashed, tatties on top - a meal of the highest comfort-food order.

Product reviews

Mumsnet best - Worst book this year - The Island - Victoria Hislop

Mumsnetter ratings

(7 reviews)
Overall /gifn/star.2.5.gif


Mumsnetter reviews

Report this review From: MildredwithTwins on 16-Sep-09 18:08 Overall rating 8.0
Gosh, I'm surprised people hated this. I thought it was really interesting how leprosy treatment has changed over the years, and that thalidomide was the cure. I'm always interested in island communities, and thought this described an interesting example of type. I didn't think the writing was poor - it didn't remind me of Dan Brown at all.

more reviews... 0 people said they found this review useful.

The small ads

Mumsnet
Report this review From: JillyG on 31-Jul-08 16:44 Overall rating 4.0
I found this to be very predictable and boring read. From the moment they mention "the island" you know it's bad and as soon as they introduce the family characters you know what is going to happen.

I usually get quite attached to characters in a good story and feel depressed when I finish a book and have no way of knowing what happens to these people. In this book it was a relief to be finished!

0 people said they found this review useful.
Report this review From: soames on 25-Jul-08 09:15 Overall rating n/a
how did this illiterate rubbish ever end up in print!!!!

0 people said they found this review useful.
Report this review From: ibelieveindreaming on 15-Jul-08 14:22 Overall rating 6.0
I disagree with the other reviews. I found this book easy to read and quite enjoyable. Not the best book ever, but certainly not the worst.

0 people said they found this review useful.
Report this review From: Anon on 07-Jul-08 14:21 Overall rating 4.0
Having enjoyed this book I did decide to give it away as it's a definite once only read. The prose was not that polished and it was not a hugely satisfying read; but it deals quite sensitively with the subject matter and makes a change to all the chick lit washing around. Not a worst book of the year - I'm writing this to give it a fair hearing!!

1 person said they found this review useful.

Showing reviews 1 to 5 of 7.

1 | 2 | next page
Shortcuts
Popular forums

Product reviews

Tools


Advice

Family recipes

Membership


About us


Other stuff